15 Best Restaurants in Reynoldsburg (Ohio)

Reynoldsburg, Ohio has plenty to offer visitors. From its charming downtown district to its outdoor recreation opportunities, there’s something for everyone in Reynoldsburg.

This city, with over 40 000 residents, offers plenty to do. There are plenty of museums and historical sites to explore. Reynoldsburg is also home to a thriving arts community, with galleries and theaters throughout the city.

Reynoldsburg, OH, offers a variety of shopping and dining options.

Start your day off with breakfast at First Cafe, have lunch at Loving Hut, and end your night with dinner at Smokey Bones – known for its delicious grills. Don’t forget to sample some local craft beers from Prost Beer & Wine Café!

Below are the top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, United States.

Best Restaurants in Reynoldsburg

1. Scali Ristorante

Scali Ristorante

Scali Ristorante is at the top of our list of best restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, which is worth the visit.

Frank and Judy Scali opened this top-ranked Italian restaurant in 1993. Since then, they have continued representing The Reggio Calabria Province of Italy with authentic meals and drinks.

Enjoy your meal while you dine in this casual atmosphere on a white-clothed table.

The members of staff are dedicated and helpful. They provide excellent services and are willing to help you with several suggestions.

Do well to try one or more of their specialties, which include capicola ham baked in broccoli sauce, Romano cheese, and layers of sirloin beef stuffed with mozzarella.

Scali Ristorante is open for business on Tuesdays to Saturdays from 05:00 pm to 08:00 pm.

Visit Scali Ristorante with your family and friends for an enjoyable dining time.

Address: 1903 OH-256, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-759-7764

2. Hickory House Restaurant

Hickory House Restaurant

Still on our list of top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, is Hickory House Restaurant, which is also worth visiting.

For over 35 years, Tony Torchia, the founder of Hickory Hou, has kept the restaurant afloat with his consistency and desire to grow.

At Hickory House Restaurant, the owners and operators see and take their customers as family and, thus, have prioritized giving excellent customer service.

Hickory House Restaurant is an excellent steak house with exciting features such as free Wi-Fi, curbside pickup, a full on-site bar, and reservations.

Some popular items include Slab of Ribs, Broccoli, Chicken Alfredo, Salads, Steaks, and BBQ ribs. They also offer fish and chips and onion rings.

Hickory House Restaurant is open to visitors from 12:00 pm to 09:00 pm on Mondays to Thursdays and from 12:00 pm to 10:00 pm on Fridays and Saturdays. The restaurant is closed on Sundays.

The vegan-friendly restaurant offers a kid’s menu, making it suitable for every family member. You can grab a takeaway too!

Address: 7051 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-861-5962

3. Prost Beer & Wine Café

Prost Beer & Wine Café

At the third spot on our list of top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, is Prost Beer & Wine Café; to get the best locally crafted beers and wines, you’d need to visit Prost Beer & Wine Café.

Since its launching in 2014, they have been famous for offering excellent food and an expansive wine list.

The staff at the restaurant are knowledgeable and approachable. They make sure that your visit to this warm atmosphere is memorable.

The food and the beer are made from fresh, locally sourced ingredients to ensure that your palates get the best sensation.

Prost Beer & Wine Café is an eclectic restaurant that offers indoor and patio dining.

On the menu are salads, sandwiches, beer, and wines. Try their stout beer, bruschetta, charcuterie board, grilled cheese sandwich, and hummus with pita bread.

Prost Beer & Wine Café is open for business from 11:00 am to 01:00 am on Mondays to Saturdays and from 11:00 am to 12:00 am on Sundays.

Make sure to join the happy hour from 03:00 pm to 07:00 pm on Mondays to Fridays and from 04:00 pm to 12:00 am on Sundays.

Address: 7354 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-694-0975

4. Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery

Tyler's Pizzeria & Bakery

Among the top restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, is Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery, which is worth visiting.

Since 2003, its founder, Bryan Tyler, has put in years of experience to ensure that the pizzeria & bakery runs at optimal quality.

Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery is built on Bryan Tyler’s passion for healthy and well-baked foods.

The baked items are from scratch, so you are assured of only fresh food when you patronize Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery.

This pizza restaurant offers outdoor seating and takeout options in a casual and cozy atmosphere.

Some suggestions to try when you visit include calzone, pepperoni pizza, cheese pizza, sausage pizza, cheese breadsticks, pumpkin and cinnamon scones, margarita pizza, blueberry chocolate chip bars, and white pizza.

Tyler’s Pizzeria & Bakery is closed on Sundays to Tuesdays but is open on Wednesdays to Fridays, from 03:00 pm to 09:00 pm, and Saturdays from 11:00 am to 09:00 pm.

Address: 7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-322-9587

5. First Watch

First Watch


Next on this list of best Reynoldsburg restaurants is First Watch, which is worth visiting.

First Watch is a breakfast restaurant that has offered breakfast, brunch, and lunch services since the 1980s to residents and visitors alike.

They provide vegan options, small plates, takeout options, a lift, and organic dishes, and they accept reservations and digital payment methods.

On the menu are eggs benedict, Belgian waffle, shrimp and grits, chocolate chip pancakes, blueberry pancakes, breakfast tacos, lemon ricotta pancakes, bravado omelet breakfast, parma skillet hash, and more.

If you can not come down to 2227 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Road, no worries; they offer delivery services too.

First Watch Reynoldsburg, OH, is open daily seven days a week from 07:00 am to 02:30 pm.

If breakfast is substantial, First Watch is the place to visit.

Address: 2227 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Road, OH-256, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-864-3447

6. Loving Hut

Loving Hut

Are you in Reynoldsburg, OH, looking for an excellent vegan restaurant? If yes, look no further than Loving Hut.

Loving Hut is a vegan restaurant that is also among the top Reynoldsburg restaurants.

Loving Hut is a fast-growing vegan restaurant offering gourmet cuisine made with excellent vegan ingredients in over 200 locations.

They also provided comfort food, healthy options, and small plates in a cozy atmosphere.

They offer; Appetizers, such as spicy nuggets and golden nuggets; entrees, such as pepper steak, Thai curry, and fettuccine alfredo; salads/Wraps, such as taco salad, caesar salad, and chicken wrap.

They also offer sandwiches & burgers, soups, drinks, aloe lemonade, blueberry bliss, Thai iced tea, and cakes!

Visit Loving Hut from 12:00 pm to 07:00 pm on Wednesdays to Saturdays. Loving Hut Reynoldsburg is closed on Sundays, Mondays, and Tuesdays.

Come alone or with your friends and family; there’s seating provision for solo and group dining.

Address: 6569 E Livingston Ave, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-863-0823

7. Smokey Bones Reynoldsburg

Smokey Bones Reynoldsburg

Still on our list of top Reynoldsburg restaurants is Smokey Bones Reynoldsburg, which is worth visiting.

Smokey Bones is an American restaurant offering excellent drinks and grills at affordable prices.

They are famous for their slow-smoked meat. The restaurant is neat, and the servers are friendly and approachable.

The menu holds exciting items such as grilled cheese, loaded nachos, loaded fries, margaritas, pretzel bones, fried pickles, smoked chicken wings, and lemonade.

Smokey Bones Reynoldsburg is open seven days a week, fourteen hours daily, from 11:00 am to 01:00 am daily.

Address: 2200 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-577-0764

8. City Barbeque

City Barbeque

City Barbeque is a smokehouse restaurant offering classic barbecue fare in a down-home setting.

Are you in Reynoldsburg looking for an excellent spot to get a well-smoked BBQ? If yes, look no further than City Barbeque.

For over 20 years, they have been home to properly smoked BBQ ribs, turkey, bacon, and the like, in Reynoldsburg.

The staff at City Barbeque is accommodating, approachable, and ready to help. The service is excellent, and so is the atmosphere. The amiable and relaxing atmosphere is aimed at making you feel at home.

Dine-in, delivery, curbside pickup, outdoor seating, and a kid’s menu are some features of this restaurant.

The menu includes salads, pulled pork, chocolate cake, beef brisket, ribs, banana pudding, and more.

City Barbeque opens on Monday- Saturday from 11:00 am – 9:00 pm and Sunday 11:00 am- 8:00 pm.

Address: 5979 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213, United States. Phone: +1 614-755-8890.

Planning a food tour of Ohio? Here is a guide on restaurants in Powell, restaurants in Canal Winchester, and restaurants in Greenville for a fun meal time.

9. Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria

Vick's Gourmet Pizzeria

One of the best places to eat in Reynoldsburg, Ohio is Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria.

If a delicious pizza is what you crave, then the family-owned Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria is the place to visit.

Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant offering excellent pizzas with superb sides since the early 1960s. Their recipe has compelled people always to return.

Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria gives back to the community by purchasing quality ingredients from local stores. Purchasing items around also ensures that the food they serve is always fresh. The quality of their food and services is paramount, and they strive to keep it up.

For food suggestions, you might want to try their gourmet Philly steak, signature portabella, and of course, make a from the variety of delicious pizzas. They also offer special deals on the weekends and Tuesdays, and Wednesdays.

This restaurant also provides takeout and delivery options to suit your want. Make sure to make a stop!

Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria opens on Monday, 2:00 pm-10:00 pm, Tuesday- Saturday, 11:00 am- 10:00 pm, and Sunday, 11:00 am- 9:00 the.

Address: 7345 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-866-7392.

10. Massey’s Pizza

Massey's Pizza

If you are a pizza lover and are in Reynoldsburg, make sure to stop by Massey’s Pizza for a memorable pizza treat.

Massey’s Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant and is, in fact, one of the best restaurants in Reynoldsburg, Ohio.

Massey’s is one of the restaurants in this town that prioritizes quality food. The question of whether you will return or not is a no-brainer.

They offer salads, subs, and a wide range of pizzas, of course. Do well to try their pizzas.

If you are not in the mood for pizza, you can try other options like a meatball sub, cheese bread, and buffalo wings. Their Italian cuisine will also crush your cravings whenever you need it to.

Massey’s Pizza opens on Monday- Thursday, 11:00 am- 9:00 pm, Friday & Saturday, 11:00 am- 10:00 pm, and Sunday, 1:00 pm- 9:00 pm.

Address: 7070 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614–868-0690.

11. Nico’s Cajun Island Cafe

Nico's Cajun Island Cafe

Among the best places to eat in Reynoldsburg, OH, is Nico’s Cajun Island Cafe, which is worth visiting.

Whether you are a lover of Cajun, American, or Creole food, Nico’s Cajun Island Cafe has something for you.

Features such as dine-in, takeaway, and outdoor seating are available at this restaurant. A visit to Nico’s Cajun Island Cafe will be one to remember after you have experienced the fantastic service.

The menu has many tasty items, including the famous blackened chicken with bowtie pasta, cajun chicken, waffles, shrimp pasta, and various sauce such as the sweet blackened and paradise teriyaki sauces.

Nico’s Cajun Island Cafe opens seven days a week from 11:00 am- 10:00 pm.

Address: 1765 Brice Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-866-6300.

12. Sakana Asion Fusion

Sakana Asion Fusion

If you are in Reynoldsburg and a lover of Asian food, we recommend visiting Sakana Asion Fusion.

The restaurant is famous for its Thai, Japanese, and Chinese dishes offered at an affordable price. The atmosphere at Sakana is relaxed and comfortable.

Their menu includes lunch specials, appetizers, soups & salads, noodles, teriyaki, hibachi, specialty rolls, entrees, and so much more.

Try their perfectly cooked Thai spring rolls, California rolls, miso soup, kung pao chicken, prawns, squid salad, and sashimi at Sakana Restaurant.

Sakana Asion Fusion closes on Monday, opens on Tuesday- Thursday from 11:00 am- 9:30 pm, Friday and Saturday 11:00 am- 10:00 pm, and Sunday 12:00 pm- 9:30 pm.

Address: 7952 E Broad St., Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-866-6160.

13. O’ Charley’s

O' Charley's


Among the top American restaurants in this town is O‘ Charley’s, which is worth visiting.

O’ Charley’s is the place to visit if you are looking for a spot to enjoy your favorite dishes while having fun and conversations.

O’ Charley’s promises to give you only the best options for food and drinks for your family and friends!

You can order dishes as a takeaway, get them delivered, pickup through kerbside, or dine in at this restaurant. You can enjoy time with your loved ones at O’ Charley’s without spending so much.

Loaded potato soup, fried chicken salad, seafood platter, garlic shrimp pasta, fried pickles, good rolls, catfish, chicken pies, tasty ice cream, beer, and lemonade, are some items on the menu.

O’ Charley’s opens on Sunday- Thursday from 11:00 am- 9:00 pm, Friday & Saturday 11:00 am- 10:00 pm.

Address: 2272 Baltimore-Reynoldsburg Rd, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-868-6963.

14. Jade’s Chinese Restaurant

Jade's Chinese Restaurant

Jade’s Chinese Restaurant is one of Reynoldsburg’s restaurants that offers delicious Chinese dining and takeout.

Jade’s Chinese Restaurant is a renowned Chinese restaurant in Reynoldsburg that is famous for its excellent food and outstanding service.

Jade’s Chinese Restaurant uses only fresh and delicate ingredients to make their customers tasty dishes.

They serve Mongolian chicken, Kang Pao chicken egg rolls, steamed dumplings, beef lo mein, etc.

Visit, and you’d not be disappointed!

Jade’s Chinese Restaurant opens on Sunday- Thursday, 11:00 am- 9:00 pm, and Friday & Saturday, 11:00 am- 11:00 pm.

Address: 8071 E Broad St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-868-3231.

15. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Number fifteen on our list is Olive Garden Italian Restaurant, and if you are craving Italian food, then Olive Garden is the place to visit.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant offers nothing less than excellent Italian dishes made from fresh ingredients and presented in a pleasant atmosphere.

Olive Garden offers features like curbside pickup, takeaway, delivery, dine-in, and others.

Sangria, fried mozzarella, shrimp scampi, chicken parmigiana, bread sticks & salad, chicken Alfredo, chicken parm, stuffed mushrooms, and stuffed chicken marsala are some popular items on the menu.

Olive Garden Restaurant opens 11:00 am- 10:00 pm on Sunday through Thursday and 11:00 am- 11:00 pm on Friday & Saturday.

Address: 2439 Taylor Square Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068, United States. Phone: +1 614-863-0106.

Planning a food tour of Ohio? Here is a guide on restaurants in Loveland, restaurants in Marysville, and restaurants in Rocky River for a fun meal time.

Plan a Trip to Reynoldsburg

So, if you’re in the mood for some time away and you’re looking for somewhere interesting to visit, we suggest a visit to Reynoldsburg, OH.

The numerous restaurants in this city will undoubtedly impress you. If you want the best Reynoldsburg restaurants, visit one or more of the restaurants highlighted in this article. You won’t be disappointed!

Plan a visit to Reynoldsburg, Ohio, United States, today!