Sea Isle City is a beautiful city in Cape May County, New Jersey, with a population of about 2,122. The city offers a dense suburban feel, with most residents owning their homes.
Besides, the city boasts numerous bars, coffee shops, and restaurants, which are great for food lovers.
With homes on the lagoons and beaches, Sea Isle City is a great place for tourists. Hence, there is always a need for people to visit these charming diners.
If you need more ideas on where to eat when you visit Sea Isle City, we have compiled a list of the best restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ, and what makes them a must-visit.
So read on as you discover your favorites and what it has in stock for you.
Best Restaurants in Sea Isle City
1. Mike’s Seafood & Dock Restaurant
First on our list of best restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ is this casual restaurant with great food gets the attention of the locals and visitors. Mike’s Seafood & Dock Restaurant provides a family environment that attracts groups of people to share fun and food. A trip to Sea Isle City is not complete without visiting this spot.
The menu comprises fresh and cooked seafood dishes sourced from the locals and made to order. Whether shrimp, scallops, clams, crab cakes, crab balls, or mussels, you will find what you are looking for. Try a plate of mussels with roasted tomatoes and pasta. You may also go for chicken sandwiches if you are not big on seafood.
Mike’s is BYOB, so you can bring your special drink and complement your meal. The service is attentive and fast, while the price is welcoming. Whatever seafood dish you crave in this city, be sure to find them in this restaurant.
Mike’s Seafood & Dock Restaurant is open Monday to Thursday, from 9 am – 9 pm, and Friday to Sunday, from 9 am – 9:30 pm.
Address: 4222 Park Rd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1936. Phone: +1 609-263-3458
2. Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria
Opened in 1999, this family-owned and operated restaurant is one of your best bets in Sea Isle City. It specializes in providing quality and tasty Italian dishes in the heart of New Jersey. Also, it is BYOB, which makes it perfect for you to pair your meal with your choice of drink.
Enjoy delicious seafood in this restaurant when you need somewhere to spend a quality evening. You may also go for pasta dishes, cheesesteaks, or chicken sandwiches and pair them with salad or French fries. The meals are tasty and tastier, with a glass of white wine straight from the heart of Italy.
In addition, the restaurant offers a relaxing atmosphere that sets the mood for the meal. The food is excellent and reasonably priced, with great service to cap off the experience. And if you want the fun to be more colorful, bring your loved ones for some Italian treats at the seashore.
Basilicos Ristorante-Pizzeria is one of the top restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ, and they are open on Sunday to Saturday, from 4 – 10 pm.
Address: 27 43rd St, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1941. Phone: +1 609-263-101
3. Mrs Brizzle’s Buns
While Sea Isle City boasts plenty of hoagie shops, Mrs Brizzle’s Buns has what it takes to sweep you off your feet. Serving breakfast, lunch snacks, and other delectable food makes it an excellent place for light meals. In addition, the restaurant is beautifully set to keep you comfortable while enjoying a relaxed vibe.
The Philly hoagies are Philly-style with Philly-sourced Italian meats, which you should taste. Another piece of heaven is the Belly Buster, made with lettuce, Provolone cheese, red olives, vinegar, onions, pepper, and Italian spices. Finally, their Italian rolls and sandwiches, especially the cinnamon buns, are worth taking a bite at.
Take a break from work today and visit this fantastic spot as you watch your food made from scratch. For a place like this, you may expect a little high price, but everything is adequately priced. Then, share fun with your other happy guests as you savor your food to the last piece.
Mrs Brizzle’s Buns is open on Sunday to Saturday, from 7 am – 5 pm.
Address: 4601 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1819. Phone: +1 609-263-2773
4. O’Donnell’s Pour House
It was a joy in 1999 when Ocean Drive opened O’Donnell’s Pour House, one of the best restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ. It is a place to indulge in Irish food and drinks and relax for special treats. Acoustic music enthusiasts would love to drive down to this spot as their favorite tunes serenade their ears.
Besides, this is a place to celebrate your little wins with delicious seafood and other items. Start with mouthwatering entrees like crab cakes, clam chowder, Barramundi, and Cajun scallops. Proceed with Wagyu beef skirt steak over mashed potatoes or sautéed spinach and French salads. Then, send it down with a glass of beverage or Irish wine and some crackles of laughter from friends and family.
The upscale casual experience you derive from this Irish pub will carry you for a long time. The service is fast and prompt, and you will have the opportunity to say hello to other gay diners. Try them today, and you won’t go wrong.
O’Donnell’s Pour House is open on Friday to Saturday, from 5 – 9:30 pm.
Address: 3907 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-2013. Phone: +1 609-263-5600
5. A Modo Mio
A Modo Mio is tucked away along the main road in Sea Isle, a casual restaurant with delicious goodness. It is a place to enjoy every crave-able item you have been looking forward to once you enter the city. Offering a welcoming environment and food made from freshly sourced ingredients is one reason you should not miss it.
Guests look forward to a great moment with Ricotta e Miele, a dish of whipped ricotta with a huge portion you can share as a group. If you would love some seafood dishes, you should go for Chef’s Special, a seafood combination with a blush sauce and tomato pasta. Chicken Parm, seafood pasta, Veal Osso Buco with saffron risotto, and Cavatelli with seafood combination are special dishes you should not ignore.
Not to forget, you can bring your own bottle, pour some nice drinks in your glass, and toast to long life and good food. You will enjoy quality time and excellent service. But, of course, the prices and food size are appealing, too. So, come and experience a piece of heaven in an American kitchen as it is one of the best places to eat in Sea Isle City, NJ.
A Modo Mio is open on Sunday to Saturday, from 11 am – 2 pm and 4 – 10 pm.
Address: 5900 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1556. Phone: +1 609-486-5455
6. Hank Sauce
This casual eatery in the heart of Sea Isle City is a must-visit once you are in the neighborhood. It offers a scintillating atmosphere for a date night and hanging out with friends. Ordering a meal here means you will be fortunate to eat made-from-scratch fresh meals.
The extensive menu has something for everyone. You will find it whether you crave pulled pork sandwiches, chicken sandwiches, Mexican food, seafood, burgers, or salad. Don’t forget to take a bottle of Hank Sauce home with you and continue the fun there.
Because the restaurant is BYOB, you can come with your bottle and drink to your delight. However, you may have to wait a bit long for your food, but it is worth it. The restaurant is warm and welcoming, offering an out-of-the-world experience.
Hank Sauce is open on Thursday to Monday, from 12 – 8 pm.
Address: 8605 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1080. Phone: +1 609-486-5132
7. Sunset Pier Restaurant
If you have always wanted to catch a glimpse of the sunset in Sea Isle City, you would love the view from this bayside restaurant. Sunset Pier Restaurant provides breakfast, lunch, and dinner to its happy guests, ready for some tasty treats. It is a charming place with welcoming vibes and an eclectic menu.
The menu star is the seafood tastily prepared to order and served piping hot. You can go for fish tacos, shrimp scampi, crab cakes, clam chowder soups, broiled scallops, or mussels. Of course, you may combine them with pasta dishes and relish the perfect flavor blend.
The seaside view from the restaurant is excellent and appealing, especially while sitting on the outside patio. However, a big surprise awaits you as you step in and meet the smiling faces of the staff, ready to treat you to an impeccable meal.
Sunset Pier Restaurant is another one on our list of top restaurants in Sea Isle City, NJ, and they are open on Sunday to Saturday, from 7 am – 2 pm and 4 – 9 pm.
Address: 86th and The Bay, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243. Phone: +1 609-263-5200
8. Rick’s Breakfast House
Opened in 1997, Rick’s Breakfast House is an American-style eatery that provides breakfast meals. It boasts a family-friendly atmosphere and delicious meals with irresistible outcomes. According to reviews, if you want to be served quickly, you should come early because of the crowd discovering what a gem this place is.
Cream chip beef is one of the best meals to start with. However, in diverse flavors, omelets, fries, sausages, waffles, French toast, egg benedicts, and pancakes are also available. The breakfast menu is huge and has something for everyone.
Everything is excellent in this charming restaurant, with fair prices and adequate food portions. The environment is sparkling clean, while the servers take care of your comfort. Do not miss trying some of the items on the menu; they are well worth your attention.
Rick’s Breakfast House is open from Sunday to Saturday, from 7 am – 2 pm.
Address: 6114 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1436. Phone: +1 609-263-0037.
Planning a food tour of New Jersey? Here is our guide on restaurants in Parsippany, restaurants in Keyport, and restaurants in Rumson for a fun meal time.
9. La Finestra Ristorante
This is another hotspot in Sea Isle City with a good ocean view. It is an upscale, casual restaurant that prides itself on its customer retention capability. La Finestra Ristorante is one of the best places to eat in Sea Isle City, NJ, if you desire a plate of seafood in a welcoming environment.
You can start with grilled artichoke and polenta with mushrooms and gorgonzola. Then, continue with the scallop and lobster special before going for dessert. You will also love to taste their sweet wines and cocktails with refreshing effects.
Moreover, the food presentation entices the appetite and makes you long for more visitations. Everyone raves about the restaurant for the same reason – it is a great place to gather with friends and family or give your partner a treat on a casual evening. So, give it a try, and you won’t regret it.
La Finestra Ristorante is open on Wednesday to Sunday, from 4:30 – 10 pm.
Address: 25 John F Kennedy Blvd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1947. Phone: +1 609-486-5033
10. La Fontana Coast Ristorante
This beautiful diner being of the best Sea Isle City restaurants brings fine dining to the coast, as it is strategically located close to the beach. It focuses on thrilling the guests with mouthwatering Mediterranean cuisine with an Italian ambiance that speaks of taste. You will also be able to view the beach from a breathtaking position as you savor the delicious goodness before you.
Everything you desire is available on the menu, so you should bring your appetite to devour the professionally customized, made-from-scratch meal. Remarkably, you can bring your own bottle and pair your meal. Gnocchi Alla Gorgonzola and Penne Scampi with delicious salads are a great combination to taste. You should also consider the wood-fired, oven-cooked Osso Buco veal shank, served with risotto and marsala demi-glaze.
The stylishly infectious Italian décor, which blends with the Mediterranean meal and exquisite view of the water, makes the restaurant a must-visit. Just a few steps from the beach, you will graciously sit on the outside patio and order your classic meal. The service is nothing short of excellence, and the staff is skilled and friendly, serving each dish with charm. One more thing, you will come as a guest and leave as a family because of the hospitality infused around the tables.
La Finestra Ristorante is open on Monday to Thursday, from 3 – 10 pm, and Friday to Sunday, from 3 – 8 pm.
Address: 5000 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1741. Phone: +1 609-486-6088
11. Andrea Trattoria II
Fans of Andrea Trattoria II is best places to eat in Sea Isle City, NJ.
Guests can testify of one thing: its excellence in crafting delicious, made-from-scratch meals. It is also exceptional in the quality of service offered, as it ensures the ambiance is welcoming and fun. So if you would miss anything in Sea Isle City, let it not be an evening with your family or friend.
Go simple by ordering chicken parm with Caesar salad, served in a parmesan bowl. You would also love to taste their burger, wrap, cheesesteak, fish, and pasta, all loaded with goodness. Finally, tasting the fluffy Limoncello dessert will convince you to come again.
Not to forget, adding a bottle of your favorite wine to the meal will give a fantastic touch to the culinary experience. So why not give it a shot today? The price is fair and modest.
Andrea Trattoria II is open on Thursday to Saturday, from 4 – 9 pm.
Address: 4216 Park Rd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1936. Phone: +1 609-263-5001
12. DeNunzio’s Brick Oven Pizza and Grille
This lovely pizzeria is one of the top Sea Isle City restaurants as it is all about great food and outstanding personalities. It is a place to spend fun moments with family and friends or just a romantic dinner with your significant other. The fresh, locally sourced ingredients give the food the desirability and irresistibility it carries.
Come for delicious gourmet pizza and pasta dishes, including subs, salads, wings, seafood, wraps, cheesesteaks, and appetizers. Happy hour is a time to experience discounts for the appetizers you select. Not to forget, there is something for your kids to entertain their taste buds and leave some unforgettable moments in their memory.
The vibes and aura that filled the restaurant had a mild effect on guests, who would always return for another awesomeness. They also offer free delivery for your convenience. So, stop for lunch and dinner, and experience the taste of heaven in a culinary atmosphere.
DeNunzio’s Brick Oven Pizza and Grille is open on Sunday to Saturday, from 11 am – 9 pm.
Address: 3500 Boardwalk, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-2151. Phone: +1 609-263-2600
13. Uncle Oogie’s Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches
If you want to taste homemade pizza in Sea Isle City, NJ, you should rush down to Uncle Oogie’s Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches. It provides a fun atmosphere to relax and devour your food, and the staff is accommodating. The ambiance creates a memorable experience, making it easier for guests to repeat their visits.
A pizza and wings meal with some wine or a soft drink wouldn’t be bad if you want something simple and filling. Chicken cheesesteaks, cheeseburgers, chicken parm, and other amazing sandwiches with salads are also available. They also offer gluten-free and vegan options for healthier feeding.
You can count on them for delivery services. So whether you desire brunch, lunch, or dinner, you will always enjoy being served here.
Uncle Oogie’s Pizzeria & Specialty Sandwiches is open on Monday to Thursday, from 11 am – 11 pm, Friday, from 11 – 12 am, Saturday, from 9 – 12 am, and Sunday, from 9 am – 11 pm.
Address: 6118 Landis Ave, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1436. Phone: +1 609-263-6086
14. Braca’s Café
Located in the city center, this outdoor and open-air restaurant is one of the best Sea Isle City restaurants. It serves classic Italian cuisine, made from scratch and to order. The atmosphere is homely and inviting; you would love it here.
Reflecting more continental fares with some Braca specialties, the menu features mainly artisan seafood and light meals served on long plates. For example, you can request a combo plate of Braca Meatballs and Crabcake – a heartwarming meal the world should know of. Try Italian salad with cheese, pepper, black olives, and leafy morsels for a lighter option.
There are dozens of dishes on the menu, the same way their prices are affordable. So, make the restaurant a must-visit whenever you come around. It promises to be fun and extraordinary. Ensure to serve yourself some beer to complement the feeling.
Address: Kennedy Blvd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243. Phone: +1 609-263-4271
15. Marie’s Lobster House
Located on Park Road in Sea Isle City, Marie’s Lobster House concludes our list of top Sea Isle City restaurants. This seafood market offers takeout options and provides fresh and cooked seafood in the daily market. All dishes are homemade and freshly cooked to retain their unique flavor.
The meals are tastefully prepared to thrill your taste bud, with a large portion for leftovers or sharing with someone. Try the Lobster Bake, comprising lobsters, shrimp, clams, baked potatoes, and corn on the cob. For those looking for non-seafood, the menu accommodates that, especially chicken sandwiches.
Sadly, they are seasonal and do not open all year. So, it would be best to find out before coming around.
Marie’s Lobster House is open on Sunday to Saturday, from 5 – 9:30 pm.
Address: 4304 Park Rd, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243-1852. Phone: +1 609-263-2526.
Want to know more top places to eat in New Jersey for fun dining? Check out our guide on restaurants in Margate City and restaurants in Sea Bright.
Plan a Trip to Sea Isle City
The above restaurants are only a few that exist in Sea Isle City in New Jersey. So, if you plan to visit the city, you have numerous options to eat from.
Why the wait? Plan a visit to Sea Isle City today!