Are you planning a trip to Keyport? If so, you might be wondering about the best places to eat in Keyport when you arrive. Don’t worry. In this blog post, we are going to enlighten you about the best restaurants in Keyport, NJ.
Keyport is a borough in Monmouth County, New Jersey, United States. This suburb has a population of 7,240, following the 2010 United States Census.
The borough is known for its seafood business enterprises, predominantly oysters in the 1800s.
The restaurants we are going to be treating are Keyport’s finest restaurants for residents and tourists alike. These restaurants are considered the best ones in the area based on their high online rating, great food, and amazing service.
Do read on!
Best Restaurants in Keyport
1. Drew’s Bayshore Bistro
Want to drink and socialize at a bistro in Keyport? Drew’s Bayshore Bistro is the spot to go to.
It is the highest-rated pub here and the first on our list of the best restaurants in Keyport, NJ. The bistro offers Cajun-tinged New American fare in a simple yet modern setting.
Drew’s Bayshore Bistro was established in 2005 by Andrew Araneo, a passionate chef in town. He used his home as the small bar, which has turned out to be Drew’s Bayshore Bistro. This establishment is a gastropub meaning a restaurant with food and drink offerings.
They serve shrimp & grits, seared sea scallops, pork du jour, crawfish etouffee, and more. Many of the food menu items are seafood dishes. We recommend their pork belly with scallion pancake for dinner. It is delicious and well-seasoned.
Some like to eat voodoo shrimp appetizers before pounding on their shrimp & grits. The restaurant offers takeaway, and preordering prior to pickup is good for Drew’s Bistro. This ensures your fast service.
The restaurant operates only in the evening, thus making it a great place for a fun night with friends and family as you dig into your seafood. They open by 5 pm and close by 10 pm.
Address: 25 Church St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1508. Phone: +1 732-739-9219
2. Keyport Fishery
Keyport Fishery is one of the best Keyport restaurants in the city. It is actually a seafood market but inside, it is a takeout restaurant that sells grilled fish, fried fish, steaks, soups, sandwiches, and platters. Keyport Fishery is located in downtown Keyport on Front Street.
They offer fresh food, lobster tail, fried shrimp, seared scallops, and raw oysters with shells. Keyport Fishery has clam strips, calamari, fried scallops, and a flounder sandwich. They serve shrimp cocktails which is a unique mixture to try out.
Soft shell crabs are cooked and served with hot sauce. Louisiana crab soup is another delicious seafood for you. The scallop platter or Haddock platter are two of the best things to order at this restaurant. The staff opens by 9 am and closes by 8 pm every day except Sundays.
Keyport Fishery is located across Raritan Bay, making it the hub for fresh fishes such as oysters, lobsters, salmons, and more. The Keyport Fishery’s building is very old, being in existence for more than seventy-three years.
Address: 150 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1070. Phone: +1 732-264-9723
3. Broad Street Diner
Broad Street Diner is a special restaurant offering special delicacies for the Keyport community. They have an extensive menu that provides the freshest and best-cooked comfort foods you can find. They also exceed expectations with international dishes making tourists want to revisit.
This keyport diner specializes in serving the best satisfying breakfast meals to customers. Their signature pancakes have received praise from customers reviewing them online. In addition, omelets, Belgian waffles, chicken sandwiches, and more are part of the breakfast menu.
Quality food, friendly staff, and a clean environment are the first impressions you get when you walk into Broad Street Diner. The restaurant is one of the few restaurants in Keyport that are open 24/7. Hence, Broad Street Diner is one of the best places to eat in Keyport, NJ, at any time of the day.
Address: 83 Broad St Front Street, Keyport, NJ 07735-1242. Phone: +1 732-497-0808
4. Lenora’s Cafe
Lenora’s Café is a breakfast café in Keyport, NJ, with quality food served in an informal setting. They are one of the top Keyport restaurants and offer dine-in, takeaway, and delivery service options to all customers.
Lenora’s Café isn’t just a casual storefront in Keyport; it is a cozy social area to chat and relax in the morning and early afternoon.
Whether it is a corned beef sandwich or fried chicken cutlet, Lenora will serve you at your table or deliver to your house. The restaurant’s extensive menu indicates the level of hard work the chefs put in behind the scenes for the sumptuous breakfast meals.
Breakfast burritos, quesadillas, Mexican chicken torta, dulce de leche, French toast, flan, and others are part of the menu. We recommend their chilaquiles and eggs with a cup of coffee. It’s a favorite for most customers. As a second recommendation, try their Cajun shrimp quesadilla with cheese and fresh avocado. It is seriously delicious.
Address: 18 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1210. Phone: +1 732-217-1483
5. Mike’s
Mike’s Giant Size Submarine Sandwiches Keyport is the best sandwich shop in the area. When we see Mike’s restaurant, we see fresh food, great service, reasonable prices, and a clean environment. The restaurant has almost all factors ticked well for them.
You might be overwhelmed by the variety of sandwiches Mike’s Giant Size provides. There is a corn beef sandwich, roast beef & provolone sub, turkey roast beef & provolone sub, and sweet pepper sandwich. There are also siders, Cuban sandwiches, and fresh hams.
You can visit Mike’s Sub Shop website online to see the full sandwich menu to be informed before going there. However, the staff will be happy to help you choose a sandwich you like. We recommend their chicken parmigiana and milkshake. The staff opens the shop daily by 9 am and closes by 7 pm.
Address: 103 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1231
6. Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits
This Keyport restaurant is a classic American eatery made with cathedral ceilings and Americana décor. The sprawling building is magnificent both in and out.
Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits has three floors, with a bar on each floor and a spacious outdoor patio. Old Glory Kitchen was once a historic building renovated into a magnificent food establishment. That is the update concerning the restaurant’s name.
Chicken parm is a good food to eat here. You can pair the chicken parmigiana with beer or stout from the bar section. Some of the popular menu items include cheeseburger eggrolls, brick-oven pizza, brick-oven chicken wings, and broiled cod. Crabby Mac & Cheese is another favorite for most customers of Old Glory.
The restaurant puts great effort into preparing its pizza from scratch using a brick oven. It is tasty, and they offer a lot of pizza flavors for those pizza lovers out there in Keyport.
The restaurant is deservedly among the top Keyport restaurants and opens by 11.30 am and closes by 10 pm on weekdays and midnight on weekends. They only issue takeouts from 11.30 am to 9 pm.
Address: 84 Broad Street, Keyport, NJ 07735. Phone: +1732-487-5555
7. Nemo
Nemo is a Japanese restaurant that serves the Keyport community with authentic Asian delicacies. Nemo specializes in Japanese and Thai foods. Thus, you are sure to get the best sushi and Pad Thai in Nemo.
They offer outdoor seating, dine-in, and takeaway options for all customers. Nemo has a great tea selection, including vegetarian food options. The restaurant’s menu highlights Pad Thai, edamame, California roll, eel, Godzilla, rainbow roll, chicken sambai, and yellowtail ponzu.
A good recommendation is their sushi rolls. There are very delicious and beckon you to eat more. Another delicious food served at Nemo is a spicy tuna hand roll Philadelphian roll. You can decide to pick chicken tempura steamed dumplings or Chinese dumplings for dinner at this Asian restaurant in Keyport, NJ.
Address: 27 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1209. Phone: +1 732-264-0660
8. McDonagh’s Restaurant & Pub
Mc Donagh’s Restaurant & Pub is an Irish pub set in a redbone circa-1900s building. The restaurant is now modernized and serves a roster of burgers and beers to the Keyport population.
McDonagh’s Pub serves craft beers that are always nice and cold. Guinness draught and bloody Mary are common drinks you can order at McDonagh’s Pub. They also serve casual digs to enjoy your beer with. These include buffalo wings, steak, lobster, corned beef & cabbage, and burgers. You can visit McDonagh’s website or Facebook page to see the full menu.
The upside of this restaurant is the live music performance that takes place there most nights. It attracts residents and tourists to dine inside while enjoying the entertainment. There is outdoor seating, and reservations can be made as well. The restaurant opens by 11.30 am and closes by midnight every day.
Address: 2 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1210. Phone: +1 732-264-0999
Want to know best places to visit in New Jersey for fun dining? Check out our guide on restaurants in Rumson, restaurants in Margate City for a fun meal time.
9. Maloneys Pub
Maloney’s Pub & Grill is a gastropub in nearby Matawan, NJ. It is less than 2 miles away from Keyport’s major access point. They provide more than a hundred rotating craft and imported beers on tap. They also provide burgers, sandwiches, barbecue, and other pub-fare classics.
Maloney’s Pub is one of the top restaurants in Keyport, NJ. Some of the pub fares they serve include bistro mussels, fish & chips, French onion soup, Portuguese shrimp, BBQ wings, and buffalo flatbread. You may like to go for something simple like a pulled pork sandwich to pair with your beer.
The pub opens by 11 am and closes by 10 pm. They offer dine-in and takeaway service options to everyone in Keyport.
Address: 119 Main St, Matawan, NJ 07747-2655+1 732-583-4040
10. Yellow Rose Diner
Yellow Rose Diner is a great restaurant offering special delicacies for the Keyport community. They have an extensive menu that provides the freshest and best-cooked comfort foods you can find. They also exceed expectations with international dishes making tourists want to revisit.
This Keyport diner specializes in serving the best satisfying breakfast meals to customers. Their signature pancakes have received praise from customers reviewing them online. In addition, omelets, chicken waffles, scrambled eggs, bacon cheeseburgers, chicken sandwiches, and more are part of the breakfast menu.
Quality food, friendly staff, and a clean environment are the first impressions you get when you walk into Yellow Rose Diner.
Address: 41 State Route 36, Keyport, NJ 07735-2020. Phone: +1 732-739-8811
11. Burlew’s Seafood and Steak
Burlew’s Seafood & Steak is one of the best restaurants in Keyport, NJ. As a seafood restaurant, their menu is filled with a wide variety of fish dishes and grilled fare. The restaurant is family-owned and has been operating since the 1920s.
They take pride in producing sweet seafood meals that are fresh and awesome. The bar section of the restaurant has a lot of alcoholic drinks plus soft drinks for all visitors. The views of the lake are one attraction that brings people to Burlew’s. You can afford to eat your seafood in the ample outdoor seating provisions while gazing into the waters.
Lobster rolls are best made at Burlew’s Seafood & Steakhouse. Theirs are seriously delicious and uniquely made. There is the availability of drunken clams, lobster bisque, crab cakes, blackened Mahi Mahi tacos, surf & turf, and Manhattan clam chowder.
Burlew’s restaurant is a great waterfront restaurant and they open by 11 am and close by 9-10 pm daily.
Address: 59 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1249. Phone: +1 732-497-0500
12. Addison Park
Do you like the idea of dining in a banquet hall in Aberdeen Township, New Jersey? Well, that’s what Addison Park is all about. It is a large hall that can accommodate from 100 to 800 guests. Hence, it is used as a venue for parties and formal gatherings.
The managing team provides in-house catering in terms of food and drinks. Though mainly meant for weddings, anniversaries, and other social gatherings, they still offer good food and drinks for hungry people who want to grab a bite.
Addison Park is undoubtedly one of the best places to eat in Keyport, NJ.
Address: 150 Nj-35, Keyport, NJ 07735. Phone: +1 732-566-9660
13. Italian Touch
Italian Touch is among the best Keyport restaurants to see. They offer world-class pizza in a casual fun atmosphere. They serve pizza, pies, steaks, lasagnas, sandwiches, seafood, grilled food, and drinks. You can expect a variety of food here at Italian Touch because their menu is broad.
This Italian restaurant is elegant, with informal tides to modern and old-world Italian cuisine. They have a spacious dining area, a full bar, outdoor seating, and live music performances. Since it’s a pizzeria, their specialty is in producing delicious, and they don’t disappoint in that department.
They have cheese pizza, which is their most popularly requested pizza. It is delicious. Vodka slice & cheesesteak pizza, buffalo chicken pizza, pepperoni pizza, and other pizza flavors are part of their pizza menu. You can be sure to enjoy scampi, garlic knots, and fried calamari at this Keyport restaurant.
A steak sandwich is reportedly a good pick for brunch or lunch. Their ribeye steak is also well renowned and applauded. Moreover, The Italian Touch doesn’t do home delivery, but dine-in and takeaway options are available. They open by 3 pm and close by 10 pm daily.
Address: 28 E Front Street, Keyport, NJ 07735. Phone: +1 732-497-5557
14. Keyport Pizza & Restaurant
Keyport Pizza & Restaurant is a neighborhood pizza hub for people in Keyport. They serve some of the most delicious pizzas, and casual digs are eaten with craft beer. This pizzeria organizes special events like beer dinners, new pizza flavor releases, and grilled fare all the time.
There are happy-hour drinks and outdoor seating for all to enjoy while dining. And the pizza is seriously delicious thanks to the traditional brick oven used in its preparation. There are three popular flavors here: ala vodka, steak pizza, and steakhouse pizza. In summary, the restaurant is a perfect place to eat Italian cuisine in Keyport, Matawan, and Hatzel neighborhoods. They open by 10.30 am and close by 11 pm daily.
Address: 42 West Front Street, Keyport, NJ 07735. Phone: +1 732-264-2667
15. Uncle Louie G
Uncle Lourie G concludes the pack of top restaurants in Keyport, NJ. It offers one of the best ice creams and their common flavors. It is located on Front Street along with many other restaurants on this list.
For decades, Uncle Lourie G has served the Keyport community delicious ice cream and sweet desserts. Thus, making this restaurant a paradise for kids in Purcellville.
Their ice cream is served in different flavors, sizes, and cones. So, kids have a lot of variety to choose from while they’re at Uncle Lourie G. The staff opens in the afternoon by noon and closes by 10 pm.
Address: 45 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735-1231. Phone: +1 732-497-0430
Also Check out our guide on restaurants in Sea Bright, NJ for a fun meal time.
Plan a Trip to Keyport
Just like we have seen, Keyport is one of the best towns to live in in New Jersey, USA. It is a beloved haven for a foodie because all the restaurants offer tasty, high-quality meals.
So, considerations of moving into Keyport should begin even without you visiting the town once or twice. This is so because of its perks – safe neighborhoods, outdoor adventure sites, availability of amenities, and of course classic restaurants!