15 Best Restaurants in Islip (NY)

Islip is a town located in Suffolk County, New York, on the South Shore of Long Island. As of the 2018 census, the town population was 330,914.

Islip is notable as the birthplace of the poet Walt Whitman and the site of the first transatlantic telephone call.

The town is also home to Long Island MacArthur Airport, which serves the Greater New York metropolitan area.

There are many great restaurants in Islip. Whether you are looking for a casual meal or a fine dining experience, you can find something to suit your taste. There are several popular chain restaurants, as well as local favorites.

You can find everything from Italian and Chinese food to steak and seafood. You can find it in Islip, whatever you are in the mood for.

Would you like to know the best restaurants in Islip, NY? Below is a perfect list.

Best Restaurants in Islip

1. The LakeHouse

The LakeHouse

First on our top restaurants in Islip, NY is The LakeHouse, a seafood restaurant in Islip that overlooks the Great South Bay. The menu features fresh, local seafood and a variety of steak and poultry options. There is also a full bar with a wide selection of wine, beer, and cocktails.

The restaurant has a casual atmosphere, and the outdoor patio is perfect for enjoying the views of the bay.

Their menu features meals like tuna tartare, lightly fried calamari, creamy tomato bisque, littleneck clam chowder, smoked nova salmon & crispy potato cake, farm green salad, LakeHouse chopped salad, and crispy duck leg confit.

They provide table service, reservations, outdoor seating, valet parking, wheelchair accessibility, alcohol service, a full bar, and a waterfront view.

The Lakehouse is open for business from 10.30 am to 2 pm and 3.30 pm to 9.30 pm on Sunday and from 12 pm to 2.30 pm and 4 pm to 10 pm from Tuesday to Saturday.

Address: 135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States, Phone: +1 631-666-0995

2. Tellers An American Chophouse

Tellers An American Chophouse

Tellers, An American Chophouse, is a steakhouse that serves dry-aged, hand-cut beef and fresh seafood. The restaurant has an extensive wine list and offers a variety of cocktails. This restaurant is arguably one of the best restaurants in Islip, NY.

The spot serves up classic steakhouse fare, including steaks, chops, seafood, and more. The restaurant also offers a wide selection of craft cocktails and wines to pair with your meal.

The atmosphere is casual and comfortable, and the staff is always friendly and attentive.

They provide wheelchair accessibility, private dining, seating, valet parking, and table service. Additionally, they have a full bar and serve alcohol. Gift cards are also available.

Tellers An American Chophouse’s working hours are 3 pm to 9 pm on Sunday, 11.30 am to 10 pm from Monday to Friday, and 4 pm to 11 pm on Saturday.

Address: 605 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-277-7070

3. Oconee East Diner Restaurant

Oconee East Diner Restaurant

If you’re looking for a delicious and affordable meal, look no further than Oconee East Diner Restaurant in Islip. This local eatery offers a variety of American classics, including burgers, fries, sandwiches, and salads.

Oconee East Diner Restaurant in Islip is a family-friendly dining experience with a home-style atmosphere. The restaurant also has a selection of breakfast items and a variety of daily specials.

The restaurant has a warm, inviting atmosphere with cozy booths and a friendly staff. The restaurant also offers a full bar with a variety of beers, wines, and cocktails. Oconee East Diner Restaurant is the perfect place to relax and enjoy a delicious meal with friends and family.

They provide table service, takeout, seating, parking, television, highchairs, and wheelchair accessibility. They also serve alcohol.

They are one of the top restaurants in Islip, NY, and are open for work from 7 am to 12 am from Sunday to Wednesday, 7 am to 8 pm on Thursday, and 7 am to 1 am on Friday and Saturday.

Address: 749 Montauk Hwy, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-581-2663

4. Da Noi Italian Restaurant

Irish Coffee Pub Incorporated

If you are looking for one of the best Islip restaurants for delicious Italian meal, look no further than Da Noi Italian Restaurant! They offer a wide variety of traditional Italian dishes and a full bar with a wide selection of wine and beer. In addition, their friendly and attentive staff will ensure a dining experience you will never forget!

They offer meals like Involtini di Melanzane, Carpaccio Di Manzo, Caprese, Polpo, Zuppa D’aragosta, Insalata Di Caesar, Insalata Tricolore, Primavera, Gnocchi Napoletana, Fettuccine Spinaci, Chicken Scarpariello, and many more Italian specials.

They provide free off-street parking, outdoor seating, table service, takeout, reservations, wheelchair accessibility, and seating. They have a full bar and serve alcohol.

They also accept American Express, Mastercard, Visa, and Discover. Free Wi-Fi and gift cards are offered.

This restaurant is open from 4 pm – 10 pm from Monday to Thursday and from 4 pm to 11 pm on Friday and Saturday. They are not available for business on Sunday.

Address: 301 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-650-6468

5. Irish Coffee Pub Incorporated

Irish Coffee Pub Incorporated

Irish Coffee Pub Incorporated is a restaurant and pub that serves traditional Irish food and drink. The pub is decorated with Irish memorabilia and has a cozy, warm atmosphere. The bar serves a variety of Irish and American beers, as well as a selection of Irish whiskies.

The menu features classic Irish dishes like Dublin-style fish and chips, corned beef and cabbage, shepherd’s pie, chicken cork, salmon O’Brien, Cajun chicken O’Reilly, and American favorites like burgers and wings.

They provide highchairs for babies, takeout, reservations, private dining, seating, and parking. They also serve alcohol.

Irish Coffee Pub is open for business from 12 pm to 8 pm on Sunday, 12 pm to 9 pm from Tuesday to Friday, and 12 pm to 10 pm on Saturday. They are not open on Monday.

Address: 131 Carleton Ave, East Islip, NY 11730, United States, Phone: +1 631-277-0007

6. Bubba’s Burrito Bar

Bubba's Burrito Bar

Bubba’s Burrito Bar is a local favorite in Islip for Mexican food. Being one of the best Islip restaurants, the restaurant is known for its fresh and flavorful burritos, as well as its friendly staff. In addition, the casual and relaxed atmosphere makes it a great place to enjoy a meal with friends.

Their dishes are prepared fresh daily using only the highest quality ingredients. They strive to provide our guests with a unique and enjoyable dining experience.

Their menu features classic burrito, naked burrito, buffalo burrito, brotato, inferno, classic taco, soft shrimp taco, border style taco, bean burrito, guilt trip, land & sea, chicka chicka boom boom, soft fish taco, and wide more taco and burrito varieties.

They provide seating, takeout, wheelchair accessibility, and parking. Bubba’s Burrito Bar is open for business from 11 am to 9 pm from Monday to Saturday. They are not open on Sunday.

Address: 513 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-650-6333

7. Tula Kitchen

Tula Kitchen

Tula Kitchen is a family-owned restaurant that serves fresh, homemade American food. The menu includes all your favorite American dishes and some unique creations you won’t find anywhere else.

The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the staff is always happy to help you find the perfect meal. So, whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, Tula Kitchen is the ideal spot for delicious Mexican cuisine.

Their menu features a chicken bowl, Tula Greek bowl, quinoa bowl, Mediterranean Spread, traditional hummus, grilled chicken sandwich, Korean BBQ burger, chicken shawarma, and Asian noodles.

They provide table service, takeout, reservations, seating, and wheelchair accessibility. They also serve alcohol.

Tula Kitchen’s is one of the best places to eat in Islip, NY. Their working hours are from 4 pm to 9 pm from Tuesday to Thursday, 12 pm to 3 pm and 4 pm to 10 pm on Friday, and 5 pm to 10 pm on Saturday.

Address: 41 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States, Phone: +1 631-539-7183

8. Americano Pie Bar Restaurant

Americano Pie Bar Restaurant

The Americano Pie Bar Restaurant is a family-friendly restaurant serving delicious American-style pies. The restaurant is located in Islip, New York, and is known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere.

The menu features a variety of savory and sweet pies and a selection of other American comfort food favorites. The Americano Pie Bar Restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family.

The restaurant also offers a full bar with a wide selection of craft beers, wines, and spirits. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming with a modern interior that is perfect for a night out with friends or a romantic dinner.

With its delicious food, great drinks, and relaxed atmosphere, Americano Pie Bar Restaurant in Islip is the perfect spot for a night of Italian-American cuisine.

Americano Pie Bar Restaurant is among the top Islip restaurants and is open for business from 4 pm to 10 pm from Monday to Thursday, 12 pm to 10.30 pm on Friday, 11 am to 12.30 pm on Saturday, and 11 am to 9 pm on Sunday.

Address: 517 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-581-8700.

Check out our guide on restaurants in Pittsford, restaurants in Saranac Lake, and restaurants in Mt. Kisco for a fun meal time in New York.

9. Mediterranean Express

Mediterranean Express

Mediterranean Express is a fantastic new Islip restaurant specializing in Mediterranean cuisine. The menu features a variety of delicious dishes from countries like Greece, Italy, and Morocco, and the restaurant has a casual, family-friendly atmosphere.

The staff is amiable and welcoming, and the food is fantastic. Mediterranean Express is the place to go if you’re looking for a new spot for a date night or a night out with friends.

Hummus, dolmadakia, baba ghannoung, falafel balls, spinach and feta, eggplant and tomato sauce, chicken souvlaki sandwich, and chicken Greek salad are all featured on the Mediterranean Express’s menu.

They provide seating, takeout, and wheelchair accessibility. This restaurant is open from 11 am to 8 pm from Monday to Saturday. They are not open on Sunday.

Address: 625 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States, Phone: +1 631-666-1216

10. Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream is the perfect place to enjoy a sweet treat! Their ice cream is made with fresh, local ingredients, and they offer a variety of flavors to choose from. So, whether you are looking for a classic taste or something more unique, they have something for everyone!

They operate a restaurant providing homemade ice cream in 25 varieties. So, sit back and relax at the picnic table in the backyard while enjoying an ice cream cone or sundae at one of their booths.

They provide takeout, wheelchair accessibility, and seating. Coyles Homemade Ice Cream’s business hours are 12 pm to 9 pm on Sunday, 3 pm to 9 pm on Monday, 1 pm to 9 pm from Tuesday to Thursday, 1 pm to 10 pm on Friday, and 12 pm to 10 pm on Saturday.

Address: 509 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-617-5014

11. Mango Tango

Mango Tango

Mango Tango is a family-friendly restaurant in Islip that serves fresh, flavorful dishes worldwide. The menu features a wide variety of options, including starters, salads, sandwiches, pizzas, pasta, and entrees.

There’s something for everyone at Mango Tango, and the friendly staff is always happy to help you find the perfect meal.

This restaurant has something for everyone, from classic Chinese and Japanese favorites to creative and inventive dishes. The restaurant is known for its unique atmosphere, with bright colors and lively music creating a cheerful environment.

They provide table service, takeaway, seating, reservations, and wheelchair accessibility.

Mango Tango is open from 1 pm to 9.30 pm on Sunday, 11.30 am to 9.30 pm from Tuesday to Thursday, 11.30 am to 10.30 pm on Friday, and 12.30 pm to 10.30 pm on Saturday. They do not open on Monday.

Address: 496 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-446-4460

12. Dang BBQ

Dang BBQ

Dang BBQ is an American-style barbecue restaurant in Islip, New York. The restaurant is known for its delicious meats cooked over a charcoal grill.

The menu features a variety of American-style dishes, including kimchi, bibimbap, and bulgogi. Dang BBQ is one of the best places to eat in Islip, NY if you’re looking for a tasty and authentic American meal.

The atmosphere at Dang BBQ is casual and inviting, and the staff is friendly and accommodating. Whether you’re in the mood for a delicious meal or just want to have a few drinks, Dang BBQ in Islip is the perfect spot.

They provide table service, wheelchair accessibility, takeout, seating, and wheelchairs.

Dang BBQ is open for business from 11 am to 9 pm from Sunday to Thursday and from 11 am to 10 pm on Friday and Saturday.

Address: 174 Islip Ave, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-581-3264

13. Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi is a Japanese restaurant in Islip, New York. The restaurant offers a variety of Japanese cuisine, including sushi, hibachi, and bento boxes. The restaurant also has a full bar, offering a variety of Japanese and international beers, wines, and spirits.

The restaurant also offers a wide selection of traditional Japanese dishes and an extensive wine and sake list. With its modern and inviting atmosphere, Sumou Sushi & Hibachi is the perfect place to enjoy a night out with friends or family.

They provide table service, wheelchair accessibility, takeout, reservations, and seating.

This restaurant is open for business from 1 pm to 9.30 pm on Sunday, 11.30 1m to 9.30 pm from Tuesday to Thursday, 11.30 am to 10 pm on Friday, and 1 pm to 10 pm on Saturday.

Address: 551 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States, Phone: +1 631-665-4427

14. Tullulah’s

Tullulah's

Tullulah’s is a cozy little spot in Islip that’s perfect for a night out with friends. The menu is perfectly curated, and the cocktails are inventive and delicious.

The vibe is casual and relaxed, and the staff is friendly and attentive. It’s the perfect place to spend an evening catching up with old friends or making new ones.

The atmosphere is casual, with a cozy, homey feel. The decor is warm and inviting, with a combination of vintage and modern elements. The menu features fresh ingredients, homemade sauces and dressings, and a variety of daily specials.

The restaurant also offers a full bar with an extensive selection of beer, wine, and spirits.

This restaurant is open for business from 12 pm to 8 pm on Sunday, 12 pm to 9 pm on Monday, Wednesday, and Thursday, and 12 pm to 9.30 pm on Friday and Saturday. They are only open on Tuesdays.

They provide BYOB, reservations, full bar service, table service, takeout, seating, and alcohol service.

Address: 12 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706, United States, Phone: +1 631-969-9800

15. White Cap Fish Co Inc

White Cap Fish Co Inc

White Cap Fish Market & Seafood Restaurant is the perfect place to enjoy fresh seafood. The market offers a wide variety of seafood, including lobster, shrimp, and scallops, and the restaurant serves delicious seafood dishes. It concludes our rich list of the best restaurants in Islip, NY.

The market also sells fresh fish, and the restaurant offers a wide variety of seafood-based appetizers and entrees.

They provide wheelchair accessibility, seating, takeout, and alcohol service. White Cap Fish Co Inc is open for business from 9 am to 6 pm from Sunday to Wednesday and 9 am to 6.30 pm on Friday and Saturday. They do not open on Thursday.

Address: 120 Main St, Islip, NY 11751, United States, Phone: +1 631-581-0125

Want to know more top places to visit in New York for fun dining? Check out our guide on restaurants in Mineola, restaurants in Penn Yan, and restaurants in Saugerties.

Plan a Trip to Islip

Islip is a beautiful city with amazing attractions that boast lots of fun. It is the perfect vacation destination for art lovers.

The above-listed restaurants are the top picks for serving good food, warm hospitality, and giving guests a memorable dining experience to look back on.

Be sure to explore these restaurants and enjoy their offerings to the fullest. Plan a visit to Islip today!