15 Best Restaurants in Penn Yan (NY)

If you are searching for the best restaurants in Penn Yan, NY, then you are in the right place.

Yates County, New York, is home to the American hamlet of Penn Yan. It serves as Yates County’s County seat.

Penn Yan is the name given to the community after an early settler and Revolutionary War veteran from Pennsylvania who built a log cabin in the area in 1793, whose hometown was Penn Yan, Ontario, Canada. As of 2020, 5,072 people were living there.

You will not be disappointed if you seek a fantastic location to eat in Penn Yan. There are various places to select from, from casual to upscale dining. In addition, you may find whatever food you are in the mood for, whether it is American, Chinese, Italian, or something else.

No matter your budget, you can enjoy a fantastic lunch at one of the numerous Penn Yan restaurants. So come hungry and discover all the tremendous possibilities this Finger Lakes town offers.

Some restaurants with unique meal experiences are Penn Yann Diner, Seneca Farms Ice Cream, Spotted Duck, Oak Leaf Café, and Keuka Restaurant.

Are you planning a trip to Penn Yan? Below is a perfect list of the best restaurants in Penn Yan, NY, to help you out.

Best Restaurants in Penn Yan

1. Penn Yann Diner

Penn Yann Diner

The Penn Yann Diner, which used to be present in practically every American town, is one of the few remaining dining establishments in the US. It is a well-known neighborhood eatery that serves classic diner fare.

A traditional breakfast from the vintage Penn Yann Diner is enough to make your day. They even have the option of a gluten-free or plant-based breakfast on request.

The Penn Yan Diner offers a variety of meals like Diner Pancakes, French Toast, Uncle Terry, Sausage Gravy, Biscuits, and Loaded Tater Tots. You could even build your omelet to your taste with veggies, meat, and cheese to give you that unique taste.

This restaurant is open for business from Sunday to Saturday from 7 am – 2 pm.

Address: 131 E. Elm Street, Penn Yan, NY 14527. Phone: (315) 536-6004

2. Seneca Farms Ice Cream

Seneca Farms Ice Cream

Seneca Farms first opened its doors in 1950. The restaurant offers a wide variety of food, but their most well-known dish is undoubtedly their fried chicken!

For your convenience, there is a drive-through at the ice cream shop. Additionally, there is a pavilion with outdoor seats.

They boast a range of more than 50 homemade ice cream recipes, and you could even Make a unique masterpiece. Their menu includes various meals in the following categories: chicken, sandwiches, seafood, pig’s plate, and salads.

Seneca Farms Ice Cream is open from 10:30 am–8 pm from Sunday to Thursday and from 10:30 am–9 pm on Friday and Saturday.

Seasonally, Seneca Farm is open from the first Thursday in March to the final Saturday in October.

Seneca Farm is also one of the best places to eat in Penn Yan, NY, and is worth adding to your list of top Penn Yan restaurants.

Address: 2485 NY-54A, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-4066

3. Spotted Duck

Spotted Duck

If you enjoy ice cream, Spotted Duck ought to be your go-to place. Spotted Duck guarantees Small Batches of Homemade Ice Cream.

Spotted Duck is one of the best ice cream restaurants in Penn Yan, NY. They provide a vast selection of ice cream flavors and toppings. The ice cream is always delicious and fresh. Always courteous and effective customer service is provided.

Some flavors include actual cookies & cream, wicked chocolate, vanilla crème, blueberry streusel (DF), caramel, etc.

They are open on Sunday to Tuesday, 12 pm to 8 pm, and Thursday to Saturday, 12 pm to 8 pm. They do not work on Wednesdays.

Address: 999 St Rt 54, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-509-3939

4. Oak Leaf Café

Oak Leaf Café

The charming Finger Lakes region is where you’ll find Oak Leaf Café.

With over 35 years of experience, oak leaf café has established itself as a renowned café in the locality.

They have an extensive menu of breakfast and lunch options, as well as an espresso bar, and are

dedicated to offering delicious food with cheerful service and consistent quality.

Breakfast quiche, Seneca sunrise sandwich, sausage gravy and biscuit, cinnamon French toast, buffalo chicken, a build-your-own salad, and fresh sandwiches, among others, are the meals contained on the menu.

They are popularly known for their delicious fry pies, which are worth a taste, and their prices are ridiculously low for the quality of food they serve.

This restaurant is open for business from Monday to Sunday from 8 am to 6 pm. It is also one of the best places to eat in Penn Yan, NY.

Address: 3173 NY-14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-0836

5. Keuka Restaurant

Keuka Restaurant

Josh Trombley, who also runs The Switzerland Inn, is the local proprietor and operator of the Keuka restaurant. He was raised in Penn Yan and is a prominent figure in the towns of Penn Yan and Hammondsport.

The menu at Keuka’s restaurant is classic traditional American fare. Starters include little neck clams, storm-sizzling chips, and baked pretzel sticks with a warm cheese sauce.

Their sandwiches should be acknowledged because most customers have treated them with the respect they merit. Grilled chicken sandwiches, hot ham and cheese, and cold brook fish sandwiches are some of the recipes available.

The menu also features a selection of steak and seafood entrees.

Kekua’s working hours are from 11 am to 10 pm from Monday – Sunday.

Address: 12 E Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-5852

6. The Olney Place

The Olney Place

The Olney place is the go-to restaurant to make the most of your time on the stunning Keuka Lake.

Olney’s site opened its doors in 2006 and is the only stop between Penn Yan and Hammondsport. Travelers always have good tales of Olney’s home after their trips.

The menu includes amazing sandwiches like the eye opener sandwich, the Zach deputy sandwich, and Seth and Paris’s daily sandwich. Their homemade soup du jour is the soup of the day and is a recommendation for anyone visiting.

This restaurant is open for business from Thursday to Sunday from 7 am – 4 pm. It is also among the best Penn Yan restaurants.

Address: 823 E Lake Rd, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-5454

7. Tavern Restaurant

Tavern Restaurant

Tavern restaurant is one of the top restaurants in Penn Yan, NY, and it offers a wide variety of food and drink choices. The atmosphere is very cozy, and the staff is amicable.

The food is fantastic, and the drinks are even better. They serve various meals, from pizza, soups and salads, specialty sandwiches, quesadillas, and wraps.

Chicken pesto wrap, grilled marinated chicken breast, deep-fried chicken fillet, open-faced ribeye steak sandwich, and a basket of rings are some courses included in their menu.

Tavern restaurant is open from 8 am to 1 am from Tuesday to Saturday, 10 am to 11 pm on Sundays, and from 8 am to 11 pm on Monday.

Address: 114 Elm St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-2436

8. Silverbird Woodfired

Silverbird Woodfired

The Silverbird Woodfired is a well-known local establishment and a typical brick oven pizza and grill restaurant in the center of the Finger Lakes.

Extensive outdoor seating, woodfired pizzas, specialty coffee, and a comprehensive menu fit for a restaurant, including a full bar, are all available at Silverbird Woodfired.

Rotating entrees are frequently provided in addition to the gastropub-style menu items, local Finger Lakes wines, and craft brewers. Available for play are a variety of antique coin-operated arcade games!

Every penny spent at the silver bird woodfired is worth it. Choose from a wide range of savory items from our extensive grilled and woodfired food menu.

Silverbird Supreme, Birds of Paradise, Red Rooster, White Wagtail, Garlic Parmesan, French Fries, Portobello Mushroom Strips, and Beer Battered Shrimp are a few of the many excellent courses.

Silverbird Woodfired is open on Sunday to Thursday, 11 am to 8 pm, and Fridays and Saturdays, 11 am to 9 pm.

Address: 133 E Elm St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-5892

Would you want to know places to eat in Mineola, NY? Here is a guide on the best restaurants in Mineola, NY, worth visiting.

9. Union Block

Union Block

You need to check out this restaurant if you’re ready for some truly delicious Italian food!

Union block is a regionally owned eatery serving comfort food influenced by Italy and the Mediterranean. They are arguably the best Italian restaurant in the whole of Penn Yan.

The dishes are all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, and the menu has something for everyone.

The menu at Union Block features all your favorite Italian classics. So, whether you’re craving a classic pasta dish or something a little more unique like Insalata Alla Cesare, Utica greens and beans, or even Polo e Salsiccia, you’ll find it here.

Pine nuts, artichoke heart and parmesan cream, fra Diavolo, mussels Bianco or marinara, and seafood puttanesca are also available in the seafood section of their menu.

The service is also excellent – the staff is always friendly and attentive, and they go above and beyond to ensure your dining experience is perfect.

The restaurant is open from Tuesday to Saturday for dinner. Their working hours are Tuesday to Saturday from 5 pm to 9 pm.

Address: Water St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 607-246-4065

10. The Wagner

The Wagner

Keuka Lake’s preferred neighborhood breakfast spot is The Wagner! Breakfast, lunch, and supper are available.

The owners are passionate about breakfast and strive to serve the best possible meal to their customers.

They use fresh, local ingredients and make all of their food from scratch.

The menu includes a variety of eggs, bacon, sausage, pancakes, waffles, French toast, omelets, and more.

Some are French toast and pancakes, steak and eggs, grilled cinnamon rounds, fruits, granola platter, and corn beef hash.

The Wagner’s working hours are Monday to Thursday, 5 am – 2 pm, Friday, 5 am – 2 pm and 4 pm to 7 pm, Saturday, 5 am – 2 pm and Sunday, 6 am – 12 pm.

Address: 124 E Elm St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-8062

11. Amity Coffee

Amity Coffee

In the center of Penn Yan, one may locate the undiscovered treasure known as Amity Coffee. They specialize in fine coffees and teas prepared by a skilled and informed crew. The coffee shop has a cozy atmosphere.

The walls are warm, dark brown, and the floors were rich dark wood. The furniture is comfortable and inviting. The coffee shop is perfect for curling up with a book and coffee in cold winter.

They run a multi-roaster business with Gimme Coffee, based in Ithaca, New York, as their anchor roaster. Every two to three months, they rotate a second roaster who comes to their establishment as a guest.

The diversity and culture this adds to their menu, along with the fresh coffees and relationships that each new roaster provides, excite them.

Drip Coffee, cold brew, latte, iced latte, cappuccino, golden milk, hot cocoa, steamer, and kombucha are some of the drinks on their menu.

Amity Coffee is open on Monday from 7 am – 5 pm., Tuesday to Thursday, 7 am – 5 pm; Friday, from 5 am – 2 pm; on Saturday and Sunday, from 8 am – 2 pm

Address: 3 Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-279-4440

12. Angel’s Family Restaurant

Angel's Family Restaurant

It isn’t easy to find excellent cuisine for practically nothing! Angel’s Family Restaurant is a small-town diner with enormous appeal but small prices.

This eatery serves purely home-cooked cuisine at a fair price and is clean.

The service is quite courteous, and the pies and muffins are cooked from scratch.

The cuisine is superb, and the ambiance is laid-back and informal. Anybody should eat at the Angel Family Restaurant.

Mushroom Swiss burgers, grilled ham and cheese, country-style biscuit and gravy, breaded chicken breast on a hard roll, and cheeseburgers are some of the meals on the menu.

Angel’s Family Restaurant is open on Sundays from 7.30 am to 1 pm. From Tuesday to Saturday from 7.30 am to 2 pm. The business does not become available for work on Mondays.

Address: 5 Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-4026

13. Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters

Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters

If you’re looking for a delicious meal and a great atmosphere, look no further than Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters!

Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters roasts specialty coffee in small batches on the lovely Keuka Lake in New York.

This restaurant offers both dine-in and outdoor seating to enjoy your meal regardless of the weather. The menu features a variety of traditional American dishes, so there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

And if you’re in the mood for a coffee, Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters has an extensive list of signature coffee drinks that are sure to hit the spot.

Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters’ working hours are from 11 am to 5 pm on Fridays and Saturdays and from 11 am to 4 pm on Sundays.

Address: 2792 State Route 54a, Penn Yan, NY 14527-8942. Phone: +1 315-536-7843

14. The Liberty Restaurant

The Liberty Restaurant

One of Penn Yan’s most giant hidden gems is The Liberty Restaurant.

You get the impression that you are entering the past as you enter. You will be seated, given ice water, and given menus.

You will regret not stopping here if this is your first visit to Penn Yan, New York. Their entire setting elevates the concept of home cooking.

Some dishes on their menu are the albacore tuna wrap, chicken broccoli alfredo, Philly cheese steak, buffalo chicken with bleu cheese, warm roast beef wrap, and little melt.

The Liberty Restaurant opens every day at varying hours.

Their working hours are Monday and Tuesday, 11 am – 2 pm; on Wednesday – Thursday, 11 am – 2 pm and from 5 pm – 9 pm; on Saturdays, 12 pm – 2 pm and from 5 pm – 9 pm; and on Sunday 4 pm – 8 pm.

Address: 221 E Elm St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-536-9036

15. Burnt Rose Wine Bar & Restaurant

Burnt Rose Wine Bar & Restaurant

Burnt Rose Wine Bar & Restaurant is a restaurant with Delicious authentic cuisine in a very outstanding environment perfectly suited for live music.

The wine bar and restaurant are beautiful spots to have dinner and a drink of wine. The menu offers a range of wines and an array of starters, main courses, and desserts.

Some dishes on their menu are Menage a Trois Board, Artichoke & Tomato Fondue, Smoked Salmon Rillettes, Hot Truck Bob, Dark Chocolate Flourless Torte, and LA Street Corn.

Burnt Rose Wine Bar & Restaurant also offers a substantial assortment of specialty drinks, beers, and cocktails that will please you if you need a drink. Burnt Rose Wine Bar & Restaurant is open for business from Sunday to Tuesday from 5 pm – 9 pm and from Wednesday to Saturday from 12 pm to 9 pm.

Address: 13 Main St, Penn Yan, NY 14527, United States. Phone: +1 315-924-3000

Would you want to know places to eat in  Saranac Lake, NY? Here is a guide on the best restaurants in Saranac Lake, NY, worth visiting.

Plan a Trip to Penn Yan

If you enjoy the small-town charm, then you’ll love Penn Yan! This quaint village is located in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country and offers a variety of activities for visitors to enjoy.

Go for a hike in one of the numerous state parks, take a picturesque drive along one of the many Finger Lakes, or try some regional wines.  Go for a hike in one of the numerous state parks, take a picturesque drive along one of the many Finger Lakes, or try some regional wines. No matter what you enjoy, you’ll find something to love in Penn Yan!