15 Best Restaurants in Long Island (NY)

Long Island is in southeastern New York State, with a dense population constituting a significant part of the Metropolitan area. It is the most populated island in the United States of America.

It is divided into four counties: the Brooklyn Kings, Nassau, Queens, and Suffolk. The Main Island and outer barrier islands surround it.

The exciting thing about Long Island is that it is a commercial aviation hub with many international and local airports. It also has significant railroads and also seaports connecting Suffolk County to the Nassau northward side.

It is indeed a place with many possibilities ready to be explored. The economy is stable and always booming because of the many activities that happen in the city.

Of course, the restaurants found here are of standardized, excellent, and professional values. It is frequented daily because of its high level of service.

Some of the top Long Island restaurants include; the Lake House restaurant, the OHK bar and restaurant, the Crabtree’s restaurant, the Café Silvium restaurant, and many more with attractive features and comfortable environments.

Are you planning a trip to Long Island, NY? Below is a list of the best restaurants in Long Island, NY.

Best Restaurants in Long Island

1. Verona Ristorante

Verona Ristorante

The Verona Ristorante is an Italian-based restaurant with many incentive dishes that makes it one of the best restaurants in Long Island, NY.

The restaurant specializes in Italian and Sicilian cuisine with special diets appealing to the vegetarian-friendly, vegan, and gluten-free options.

The services rendered here are top-notch, with quality meals and professional staff always steady to attend to her customers.

Interesting meals you can find here include: Panini served on ciabatta bread, grilled chicken, red onion, melanzane, roasted peppers, sliced steak, fresh mozzarella, breaded chicken, Margherita, palate tomatoes, spicy buffalo chicken, broccoli rabe, hot sausage, cherry peppers, citrus dressing, melted mozzarella in a scampi sauce served with roasted potatoes, pasta, seafood, breaded salmon, arugula, regular coffee, hot tea, cannoli, Italian cheesecake, Strega, port wine, appetizers, house cocktails, and so many lunch and dessert options.

The fair price range provides a comfortable environment for the guests to enjoy their meals.

Exciting features include the lounge, takeout options, free wifi, reservation centers, table services, credit card acceptance, television display options, outdoor seating, master card acceptance, buffet, and parking lot space.

The restaurant is open on Mondays to Thursdays (12:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Fridays and Saturdays (12:00 pm – 11:00 pm), and Sundays (12:00 pm – 9:00 pm).

Address: 1255 Melville Road, Farmingdale, New York. Phone: +1 516-249-0000

2. Rumba restaurant

Rumba restaurant

The Rumba restaurant is popular on the long island waterfront that is worth adding to your list of best places to eat in Long Island, NY.

It is a unique dining spot for visiting guests specializing in American, Caribbean, and Sea cuisine.

They also have room for incentive dishes and other innovations.

The menu highlights; codfish with coconut risotto, green curry rice, tacos, well-dressed salads, mani, empanadas, cowfish, burgers, buttered bread and ham, vegetable stew, margarita, roasted turkey, grilled chicken wings, boiled potatoes, fries, cocktails, key lime pie, sausage rolls, chicken pies, and assorted beverages.

The ambiance of this restaurant is cozy and relaxing, making it a visitor’s favorite.

Their services are standardized, and their waitpersons are kind and friendly to customers.

It also has features like game centers, a kid’s menu, free parking lot space, reservation centers, a flat television screen for displaying movies and football matches, accepts credit cards with special event centers for occasions.

It is open for business on Mondays to Thursdays (12:00 pm – 9:00 pm), Fridays (12:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Saturdays (11:30 am – 10:00 pm), and Sundays (11:30 am – 9:00 pm), with an exception on Wednesdays.

Address: 43 Canoe Place Road, Hampton Bays, Southampton, New York. Phone: +1 631-594-3544

3. Pontos Taverna restaurant

Pontos Taverna restaurant

The Pontos Taverna restaurant is located on long island in New York. It is a Greek and European-based restaurant with incentive and tasty meals cutting across breakfast, lunch, and dinner options.

The dishes they offer include cheese, hamburger, cucumber garlic onion sauce, chilled garlic potato puree, homemade caviar spread, spicy mashed feta spread served with pita, fried potatoes, pontos style orzo, baked giant white beans, dolmades, soda, merlot blend, fried calamari, sandwich, beef, rizogalo rice pudding, titania chicken chunks, Greek seasoned beef patty, assorted beverages, and wine bar options.

The services are high quality, and the environment is accessible, calm, and relaxing.

Features like the saloon, gyming center, spas, credit card options, table services, seating options, highchair accessibility, and reservation centers are domiciled here.

The restaurant is open on Tuesdays to Thursdays (12:00 pm – 8:00 pm), Fridays, and Saturdays (12:00 pm – 9:00 pm), with exceptions on Mondays and Sundays.

Address: 7 Isaac Street, Norwalk, CT. Phone: +1 203-354-7024

4. Lobster Roll Restaurant

Lobster Roll Restaurant

When you think of enjoying tasty meals, think of a place like the Lobster Roll restaurant. It serves American cuisine with other incentive dishes that also apply.

Quality meals include lobster salad, seafood options, chowders, homemade pies, grilled chicken wings, burgers, sandwiches, steaks, assorted beef, flavored drinks, a kid’s menu, and full-bar wine options.

The environment is located towards the end of the island, so it is relaxed and comfortable for enjoying tasty meals.

It also features summer garden flowers, beach balls, picnic tables, a flat television screen, indoor decorations, outdoor seating, master card options, accepts credit cards, and table services with free parking lot spaces.

The opening hours are on Mondays and Thursdays (11:45 am – 4:45 pm) and Fridays to Sundays (11:45 am – 8:00 pm), with exceptions on Tuesdays and Wednesdays.

Address: 1980 Montauk Highway, Amagansett, New York. Phone: +1 631-267-3740

5. Brasitas restaurant

Brasitas restaurant

The Brasitas restaurant is a Spanish and Latin-based restaurant in the long island city of New York.

This is another beautiful restaurant to enjoy tasty meals in generous portions and at fair prices.

It has a neat environment with enough space for the dining tables, making it comfortable for the guests to enjoy their meals.

The Brasitas restaurant also offers vegetarian options because of the mixed people visiting the eatery.

Exciting dishes include arugula salad, arroz con pollo, garlic tomato sauce, chimichurri sauce, hamburgers, sandwiches, Caesar salads, buttered bread, roasted pork, grilled chicken sauce, chicken wings, boiled potatoes, shrimp, fried steaks, toasted bread and tea with assorted wine options.

Some other features are reservation settings, parking lot space, table service, accepts credit cards, visa options, and full bar options with hang-out gardens.

The opening hours are Mondays to Sundays (12:00 pm – 10:00 pm). Feel free to add this restaurant to your list of the best Long Island restaurants.

Address: 954 East Main Street, Stamford, New York. Phone: +1 203-323-3176

6. Maureen’s Kitchen

Maureen's Kitchen

An exploration of the food scene of Long Island will not be complete without visiting Maureen’s Kitchen, one of the top restaurants in Long Island, NY.

Maureen’s Kitchen is a quality food-based café specializing in American dishes. Consider excellence, quality, quantity, and professional services; owe it to Maureen’s Kitchen.

Maureen’s Kitchen is one of the most visited eateries in Long Island because of its specialty in homemade meals.

You can enjoy assorted kinds of meals here, ranging from scrambled eggs, ham steaks, corn beef hash, poached eggs, cereals, American cheese, omelets, spinach, tomato stew, mushrooms, smoked fish, sausage rolls, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, pastrami, fresh solution, onion pepper stew, boiled potatoes, bacon on cheese roll, pancakes, stuffed French toast, croissants, buttered roll, real maple syrup, homefries, cocktails, and wine bar options.

The ambiance is cozy and attractive, with so many trees that beautify it and allow one to relax well.

You can also find features like takeout, parking lot space, table service, wheelchair accessibility, grilled spots, wine bars, resort gardens, reservation centers, event auditorium for special occasions like birthdays and parties.

The opening hours are Mondays to Fridays (6:00 am – 3:00 pm), Saturdays, and Sundays (7:00 am – 1:45 pm).

Address: 108 Terry Road, Smithtown, New York. Phone: +1 631-360-9227

7. The Capital Grille restaurant

The Capital Grille restaurant

The Capital Grille restaurant is an exceptional restaurant with special offers and incentive dishes.

The restaurant has a scented and scintillating aura that blends with the quality of its meals and services.

One of their values is to uphold healthy food options and helps the customer eat according to their diets.

The menu highlights appetizers and soups, caramelized French onion soup, Caesar salad with cream and toppings, shrimp cocktail, hot cherry peppers, tomato salad with champagne vinaigrette, clam chowder, seared salmon, roasted chicken breast, mushroom, risotto, creamed spinach, mashed potatoes, tuna with gingered rice, white soy, chocolate cake, strawberries, fresh raspberries, and ice-cream.

So friendly are their waitpersons with quick responses to the offers of their customers.

They also offer free delivery services, a kid’s menu, accept credit cards, free Wi-Fi, display football matches on the television screen, lounge, swimming pool, and table services.

They are open on Mondays to Thursdays (11:30 am – 9:00 pm), Fridays (11:30 am – 10:00 pm), Saturdays (4:00 pm – 10:00 pm), and Sundays (4:00 pm – 9:00 pm).

Address: 230 Tresser Beloved Street, Stamford, New York. Phone: +1 203-967-0000

8. Café Baci restaurant

Café Baci restaurant

The Café Baci restaurant Italian based restaurant with a track record of tasty meals and quality meals.

It is one of the most frequented eateries on long island, with people visiting from far to enjoy a good meal.

Their menu cuts across breakfast, lunch, and dinner options with dessert options, and they are served well.

Tasty meals like the lasagna served in generous portions, meatballs, mussels, flatbread, Italian chopped salad, shrimp salad, fresh mozzarella, roasted chicken, calamari fritti, garlic white wine sauce, spaghetti, tomato sauce, tortellini, mushrooms, chocolate syrup, cappuccino, raspberry jam, sweet Italian sausage, seafood options.

The environment is excellent, with natural features for the guests to feast their eyes on.

Other features like free wifi, television screens, credit card acceptance, high chairs, reservation centers, and full wine bar options are available here.

The restaurant is open for business on Sundays to Thursdays (12:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Fridays, and Saturdays (12:00 pm – 11:00 pm).

Address: 1636 Old County Road, Westbury, New York. Phone: +1 516-832-8888.

Are you planning a food tour in New York? Here is a guide on restaurants in NoHorestaurants in Saranac Lake, and restaurants in Ogdensburg for a fun meal time.

9. Valencia Luncheria restaurant

Valencia Luncheria restaurant

The Valencia Luncheria café offers quality and incentive meals in generous portions. It serves Latin, Spanish, and Venezuelan dishes.

Consider visiting this eatery for a convincing story of how you encountered a good meal.

A glimpse of their menu is a variety of dishes which includes spinach stew and salad, cheese, ginger pork, chicken salad, fried eggs and chicken stew, buttered bread, blackened turkey, beef, white beans and pulled pork, calamari salad, black beans with sour cream soup, cheeseburger, sweet plantain and lime corn with assorted beverages and sweet drinks.

Try out this place; the ambiance is relaxed and captivating, with hardworking waitpersons always on duty.

You can also see exciting features for livelihoods like fantastic music, parking lot space, takeout, table services, wheelchair accessibility, outdoor seating, and credit card acceptance.

The opening hours are Mondays to Thursdays (11:00 am – 9:00 pm), Fridays and Saturdays (8:00 am – 10:00 pm), and Sundays (8:00 am – 8:00 pm).

Address: 164 Main Street, Norwalk, New York. Phone: +1 203-846-8009

10. Cowfish Restaurant

Cowfish Restaurant

The Cowfish restaurant is an American-based restaurant with an exciting food menu. The vegetarians have not left out here because the restaurant respects customers’ value options.

Their meals include appetizers, breakfast, lunch, dessert, and dinner.

The menu highlights fish sandwiches, cornbread, Brussels sprouts, roasted shrimp, tacos, chicken stew, grilled pork, spiced pepper beef, assorted soups, toasted bread and hot coffee, fried potatoes, and plantains.

Their hostess, staff, and bartenders are all great and professional in their deliveries.

The restaurant’s atmosphere is always lively, with reasonable price offers making it among the best Long Island restaurants.

You can also find seaboats, a zoo, parking lot space, outdoor seating, and event centers for special occasions.

The opening hours are Mondays to Thursdays (12:00 pm – 9:00 pm), Fridays (12:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Saturdays (11:30 am – 10:00 pm), and Sundays (11:30 am – 9:00 pm), except Tuesdays.

Address: 258 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, Southampton, New York. Phone: +1 631-594-3868

11. Crabtrees Restaurant

Crabtrees Restaurant

The Crabtrees restaurant is an American-based restaurant that serves tasty meals. It should be added to your list of best places to eat in Long Island, NY.

The workers are neat and prompt to orders being made by the customers.

Assorted delicacies served here include seafood cuisine, pumpkin stew, cheesecakes, olive oil over butter, grilled octopus, roasted duck, fries, creamed dressed salads, mussels, halibut, appetizers like omelets, tender chicken breasts, sandwiches, chopped vegetables, and cocktails.

The ambiance is quite cozy, with a sofa for relaxing after eating.

Features include flat television screens, saloons, barbeque spots, private dining for families and groups, table service, and a full wine bar.

They are open on Sundays (11:30 am – 3:00 pm, 4:00 pm – 8:30 pm), Tuesdays (5:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Wednesdays to Fridays (12:00 pm – 3:00 pm, 5:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Saturdays (5:00 pm – 10:00 pm) with exceptions on Mondays.

Address: 226 Jericho Tpke, Floral Park, New York. Phone: +1 516-326-7769

12. Chachama Grill

Chachama Grill

The Chachama Grill is a famous eatery on long island with beautiful surroundings. They specialize in American cuisine with many grill menu options.

You can enjoy varieties of tasty meals here, ranging from sausage rolls, meat pies, unique herbs and seasonings, fries, rice, chicken stew, grilled pork, delicious chops, salads, and a variety of wine bar options.

So attractive and comfortable is the environment with friendly waitpersons.

Other features are the cinema, parking lot, television screen, table service, reservation centers, outdoor seating, and lounge.

They are open for business on Mondays to Fridays (11:30 am – 10:00 pm) and Saturdays and Sundays (5:00 pm – 10:00 pm).

Address: 655 Montauk Highway, East Patchogue, New York. Phone: +1 631-758-7640

13. Mediterraneo restaurant

Mediterraneo restaurant

Next on this list of top restaurants in Long Island, NY is The Mediterraneo restaurant, an Italian-based eatery that offers quality delicacies.

You can trust this eatery for quality meals with generous portions and fair prices.

The Mediterraneo restaurant is also given to humanitarian services.

Assorted dishes found here include soft poached eggs, butternut squash soup, grilled calamari, mixed lettuce, roasted walnuts, chilled seasonal oyster, grilled scallops, lobster salad, crusted halibut, chicken breast, pizza, wheat pasta, sautéed spinach, broccoli rabe, mashed potatoes, tomato stew, fresh ginger, and assorted meats and meatballs.

The atmosphere is relaxed, with pleasant staff and free delivery services.

Added to the beauty of the environment are resort gardens, sofa spots, a game center, television screens, interior and exterior decorations, and trees.

The Mediterraneo restaurant is open on Mondays to Thursdays (11:30 am – 4:00 pm, 5:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Fridays and Saturdays (11:30 am – 4:00 pm, 5:00 pm – 10:30 pm), and Sundays (11:00 am – 4:00 pm, 5:00 pm – 9:30 pm).

Address: 366 Greenwich Avenue, Greenwich, New York. Phone: +1 203-629-4747

14. The LakeHouse Restaurant

The LakeHouse Restaurant

The LakeHouse restaurant is a perfect place to enjoy beautiful meals. The restaurant has earned itself a name over the years for its consistency in the quality of its outputs.

It serves American cuisine and assorted seafood options.

Other delicacies like scallops, cod, fried rice, scrambled eggs, meat stew, salads, cheese with toppings, sausage rolls, tacos, grilled chicken wings, barbeque, tomato pastries, boiled crabs, mushrooms, black beans, and chilled drinks.

Their waitpersons are intelligent, friendly, and active in their services.

Features like free wifi, parking lot space, hang-out space, gardens, and television screens are installed to add to the livelihood of the surroundings.

Opening hours for business are Mondays to Saturdays (12:00 pm – 10:30 pm) and Sundays (10:30 am – 2:00 pm, 3:30 pm – 9:30 pm).

Address: 135 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore, New York. Phone: +1 631-666-0995

15. Café Silvium

Café Silvium

The Café Silvium restaurant is a classic eatery with assorted meal options.

The outdoor patio, fire pit, and full bar create beautiful scenery for an excellent dining experience.

Unique and outstanding are their dishes, and there is no dull moment around the environs.

You can also find incentive dishes like fried rice, fries, noodles, assorted meats, chicken stew, tuna, tacos, and lunch and dinner options with chilled drinks.

The environment is superb, with a relaxing atmosphere and it is also recognized among the best restaurants in Long island.

They are open on Mondays to Thursdays (12:00 pm – 9:00 pm), Fridays (12:00 pm – 10:00 pm), Saturdays (11:30 am – 10:00 pm), and Sundays (11:30 am – 9:00 pm).

Address: 43 Canoe Place Road, Hampton Bays, Southampton, New York. Phone: +1 631-594-3544.

Also, check out our guide on restaurants in Penn Yan, restaurants in Pittsford, and restaurants in Mt. Kisco for a memorable meal time in New York.

Plan a trip to Long Island

Exciting features that make for long-lasting life experiences are all found here.

Aside from the tasty meals here, it is also a good place for tourism and sightseeing. You can bear witness to this fact with just a visit.

Thrilling meals, a fantastic atmosphere, and unique seaports and parks.

Set a date in your free schedule for leisure in this beautiful city.