Take an exciting trip to Fort Atkinson in Wisconsin to enjoy a quiet and pleasing moment.
Known primarily for being home to The Fireside Dinner Theatre, which presents professional Broadway musicals throughout the year, this city in Jefferson County has a lot to offer diners.
Explore the food scene of Fort Atkinson and indulge your taste bud from the menu of your chosen restaurant. There is much to discover here, whether Italian cuisine or American favorites. As such, it will not be surprising that you are confused about where to dine and what to eat.
Don’t worry; we have that figured out already.
Would you want to know the best restaurants to eat at in Fort Atkinson? Below is a perfect list.
Best Restaurants in Fort Atkinson
1. Paddy Coughlin’s
First on our list of best restaurants in Fort Atkinson, WI is the locally owned and operated Paddy Coughlin’s – a popular restaurant that serves delicious Mexican favorites. There is an atmosphere of excitement surrounding which keeps diners relaxed as they relish their portions. The ingredients are freshly sourced, home-cooked, and served hot to appeal to your appetite.
The eclectic menu features every item you can find in an authentic Mexican kitchen and is nicely combined for a more flavorful meal. From nachos, tacos, and fajitas to enchiladas, burritos, pulled pork, chips and salsas, and burgers. In addition, the bar always has good, smoothly mixed margaritas that would pair with your meal.
Many guests flock to this restaurant gem to explore new favorites and relish the blend of fun vibes. The interior décor does not look back in providing a warm welcome. Also, the service is top-notch in all its descriptions – the best for a memorable casual dinner. So don’t think twice before stepping in.
Paddy Coughlin’s is open from 11 am – 9 pm, Monday to Saturday.
Address: 14 Sherman Ave E, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-1864. Phone: +1 920-397-7776
2. The Fireside Restaurant
Opened in 1964, The Fireside Restaurant has been a food entertainment hub featuring fine dining and others. It is family-owned and operated, which provides an exceptional culinary experience as one of the top restaurants in Fort Atkinson.
All you need to do is to come with your appetite and let it guide your meal choice.
Big Easy Jambalaya is an easy way out if you need clarification about what to order. It contains gulf shrimp, chicken pepperonata, andouille sausage, and Louisiana creole rice. French onion meatloaf, steaks, ravioli, chicken feta Florentine, and seafood dishes are other fantastic food you should try. Then, water it with a bottle of white wine, offering a bit of Italy to your taste bud.
Before going to a musical concert or movie show, you stop for a dinner buffet so your tummy does not have to remind you of food in the middle of the show. Not to forget, you can shop for your favorite items in the lovely shop inside the Fireside. All the same, you should get ready for an all-in-one fun moment as you arrive.
The Fireside Restaurant is open from Monday to Saturday, from 8:30 am – 8 pm, and Sunday, from 8:30 am – 5 pm.
Address: 1131 Janesville Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2406. Phone: +1 800-477-9505
3. Mangiami Italiano
This bistro-style restaurant featuring Italian cuisine is in the heart of downtown Fort Atkinson. It provides the perfect setting for a romantic dinner or laughter moments with friends and family. However, you may need to call ahead for a seat reservation to give the best experience.
Try Shrimp Puttanesca, comprising shrimp, capers, olives, tomato, and garlic in spicy red sauce for your dining. Then, request a chilled Italian wine to cool the nerves. Finally, if you love pasta dishes, you should taste the made-from-scratch pasta rags or lasagna with chicken Alfredo.
In addition, the restaurant is perfect for a night out without the kids to have fun with your significant other. The décor is nicely set for a laidback feel. So, come in the evening for an unforgettable dining experience. It is truly one of the top restaurants in Fort Atkinson.
Mangiami Italiano is open from 5 – 8 pm on Tuesday to Saturday.
Address: 226 S Main St, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2228. Phone: +1 920-397-7790
4. Stagecoach Inn
One of the best places to eat in Fort Atkinson is Stagecoach Inn. This casual eatery in Fort Atkinson serves lunch, dinner, and late-night meals. Stagecoach Inn is prestigious for providing excellent food in a friendly environment.
The menu features expansive items that are flavorfully curated to entice your appetite. A plate of steak and salad will be nice for light dining. Then, a bottle of Spellbound is all you need to keep the night going. It features vivid and lush with highlights of vanilla and classic crème Brulee.
Stagecoach Inn is open to accepting a group, and there is room for everyone to make their choices and enjoy premium-quality services. You will be welcomed at the door with smiling faces, ensuring your comfort until you step out. Weekend nights are the best to unwind and ease stress.
Stagecoach Inn is open Monday to Thursday, from 4:30 – 9:30 pm, Friday to Saturday, from 4:30 – 10:30 pm, and Sunday, from 3:30 – 9:30 pm.
Address: 11946 N State Road 26, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-9403 Phone: +1 608-868-3850
5. Scottie’s Eat-Mor
Although not your kind of fancy place, Scottie’s Eat-Mor is perfect for a classic American breakfast. It offers seating around the grill to give you a view of how your food is prepared. Besides, the food is made from scratch and comes out hot and delightful.
A simple breakfast of veggie omelets and a cup of coffee is cool if you do not mind. You may also consider biscuits, gravy, pancakes, burgers, sausage, and dietary options.
Everyone eats together in this local diner. So, get ready to experience the best of small-town American dining. The food has generous portions and is cheaper than you can get elsewhere. So, whether you want a quick bite or grab something to eat on the go, you will indeed have a nice meal to keep you filled all day. Even though the restaurant is simple, you will love to dine here again.
Scottie’s Eat-Mor is open from Monday to Saturday, from 6 am – 1 pm, except on Friday, which is from 6 am – 5 pm.
Address: 124 N Main St, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-1827. Phone: +1 920-563-2900
6. Island Bar and Grill
Another on our list of best restaurants in Fort Atkinson is Island Bar and Grill, a waterfront bar on the Rock River in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin.
Come for a lovely brunch, lunch, dinner, or late-night meal, and you won’t be disappointed with your choice. It is off the beaten path but offers the comfort of an upscale diner.
Choose a dish of chicken nacho from the expansively creative menu, with lots of shredded chicken and deliciously packed goodness. Steak bites with fries, seafood, and burgers are other options guests can’t keep their hands off. A free refill of iced tea or soda is to pair with your food. However, you may go to the full bar for any delicious beverage or margarita.
You would love dining in a cozy environment with soft music serenading the ear. Both indoor and outdoor seating options are fantastic, depending on your mood. If you want to enjoy the view of the water while eating, you should choose to sit outside. The massive yard on the water with boat slips, picnic tables, and live music make it a hotspot for a summer weekend getaway.
Island Bar and Grill is open from 11 – 12 am Sunday to Saturday.
Address: W7545 Blackhawk Island Rd, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-9578. Phone: +1 920-563-2757
7. Brock’s River Walk Tavern and Grill
One of the best places to eat in Fort Atkinson is this locally owned and operated small-town bar and grill. Brock’s River Walk Tavern and Grill is a place to stop for a quick bite and provides consistently delicious food.
The menu has enough items to consider, including steaks, burgers, wings, patty melt on a Reuben, and a prime rib sandwich. A good beverage drink will satisfy your thirst and combine with your meal.
While offering a small-town feel, the atmosphere is inviting and perfect for weekend getaways. You can bring your friends and family and share some fun moments. The relatively low prices are great if you are low on a budget. You will also enjoy the professionalism of the wait staff.
Brock’s River Walk Tavern and Grill are open on Sunday to Thursday, from 11 – 2 am, and Friday to Saturday, from 11 – 2:30 am.
Address: 99 S Main St, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2011. Phone: +1 920-542-1045
8. Tavern on Rock
If you long to dine in a nice-looking restaurant with eclectic offerings, Tavern on Rock is an ideal place. The atmosphere is pleasant, and the price is fair for any dish you crave. All ingredients are freshly sourced and cooked to perfection to entice your appetite.
Whether you desire a good lunch or dinner, the stage is set for a unique culinary experience as the menu displays a large selection of dishes. You will never go wrong with your choice, from meatloaf to chicken strips, Philly and gyro, steaks, sauces, salads, and seafood dishes. The restaurant also serves good cocktails, well mixed to go down smoothly.
Walk in and grab a seat. Then, request your choice of meal as you sip your favorite drink. The atmosphere makes an excellent blend of what you are set to enjoy. Moreover, the servers always display a smiling disposition, which is ideal for special deliciousness.
Tavern on Rock is open on Sunday to Thursday, from 11 am – 11 pm, Friday, from 11 – 12 am, and Saturday, from 11 – 2 pm.
Address: 29 Sherman Ave W, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-1836. Phone: +1 920-397-7468
9. Beauty and the Bean
This is one of the favorite spots in Fort Atkinson that visitors and locals cannot stop talking about. It is a nice place for breakfast and lunch, with a fun and relaxed atmosphere. It is a coffee hotspot and provides different flavors with an irresistible appearance.
They have the best homemade soups, salads, desserts, and sandwiches. You must taste great coffee here to enjoy a complete meal experience.
Beauty and the Bean never disappoint regarding taste and quality service. Its local, laidback vibe releases a calming effect on guests, which is why they repeat their visit. This place is highly recommended if you want a place to hang out with your loved ones.
Beauty and the Bean are open Monday to Friday, from 6 am – 4 pm, and Saturday, from 7 am – 3 pm.
Address: 207 Milwaukee Ave E, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2032. Phone: +1 920-563-4938
10. River Front Family Restaurant
This great restaurant offers a large selection of breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Whenever you pass through Fort Atkinson, you should stop in and have an exciting moment with your pallet. There is a large selection of food on the menu.
The Mediterranean omelet, pancakes, bacon, New York strip, hash brown, and cinnamon raisin toast are highly recommended for breakfast. Greek Skillet will be spot on for lunch. It features hash browns, gyro meat, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, potatoes, and feta cheese.
All these make it stand out as one of the best Fort Atkinson restaurants.
Walking through the doors feels like walking into a beautifully kept and decorated oasis. Besides, you will be served significant portions at a reasonable price. The service is excellent and best for morning dining.
River Front Family Restaurant is open Monday to Saturday, from 6 am – 9 pm, and Sunday, from 6 am – 8 pm.
Address: 1317 N High St, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-1255. Phone: +1 920-563-5070
11. Fort 88 Smokehouse + Bar
Locally owned and operated, Fort 88 Smokehouse + Bar is a family-style restaurant that focuses on serving briskets. However, it has everything, from quality service to creating meals and a rustic ambiance.
The food is prepared to order and comes out hot and yummy. You can order briskets and select from the three BBQ sauces to suit your cravings. Appetizers, desserts, salads, soups, and sandwiches are also available. So, you have a lot to choose from.
You can sit at the bar and sip a beer bottle if you want a quiet dinner. However, you can hook up with friends and family and have everyone smack their lips with their flavorful favorites. Excellent food at excellent prices is what you will get for making this restaurant your must-visit spot.
Fort 88 Smokehouse + Bar is open from Monday to Thursday, from 11 – 12 am, Friday, from 11 – 2 am, and Saturday and Sunday, from 11 am – 10 pm.
Address: 855 Lexington Blvd, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-1094. Phone: +1 920-397-7148
12. Salamone’s Italian Pizzeria
Opened in 1981, Salamone’s Italian Pizzeria is family-owned and operated, serving fresh Italian favorites. With generous portions on your plate, you have a lot to savor. In addition, the super-friendly ambiance makes a perfect evening outing.
If you doubt what to eat, a plate of an Italian entrée, comprising a pasta dish, special salad, and broccoli soup, will be fantastic. Aside from pizzas, another option is fried cheese curd, calzones, or chicken marsala. Kids also have their menus, and yours will be pleased to select their favorites.
As one of the best Fort Atkinson restaurants, this pizzeria has a lot to offer, including outdoor seating, which allows you to view the world from the lens of food. Moreover, you will enjoy fantastic service, and your overall experience will be exciting.
Salamone’s Italian Pizzeria is open from Sunday to Thursday, from 4 – 10 pm, and Friday, from 4 – 11 pm.
Address: 1245 Madison Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-1049. Phone: +1 920-563-9217
13. Cafe Carpe
Another family-owned and operated food place in Fort Atkinson is Cafe Carpe. It serves food, wine, and beer to visitors and locals who come in hungry and leave filled. Again, the ambiance has something to remind us of the past.
This family-friendly café on the Rock River offers a vast menu with mostly homemade food. Grilled sandwiches, cold sandwiches, and desserts with different combinations of tastes are served. They also have a diverse selection of beers on tap and wines you would love.
Aside from the food, the acoustic musical concert in the place keeps it warm and vibrant. The weekend evenings have something to offer your memory. There is nothing to be disappointed about the place as it provides a good chance to get away from work and enjoy life.
Why not enjoy yourself in one of the top Fort Atkinson restaurants?
Cafe Carpe is open on Tuesday to Friday, from 11:30 am – 10 pm, and Saturday, from 4:30 – 10 pm.
Address: 18 S Water St W, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2027. Phone: +1 920-563-9391
14. Fat Boyz
This gem is in the heart of Fort Atkinson, with flavorful food and fine dining. Fat Boyz is a place you would love to spend time with friends and catch up on old times. It serves a combination of dishes, freshly cooked and served to order.
For superb lunch, start your trip with New York Strip sandwich with potato fries, wedges, or chips. Then, add steak served on a soft Hoagie-style bun and a side au jus. Seafood is another soft spot for guests here.
Come for Friday night fish fry, and you will come again for the same purpose. The lovely décor, live music, cozy atmosphere, and quality service make up a terrific dining experience. You can’t go wrong here.
Fat Boyz is open from 11 – 2 am from Sunday to Saturday.
Address: 219 S Main St, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2227. Phone: +1 920-563-3051
15. Fort Atkinson Family Restaurant
Concluding our list of best restaurants in Fort Atkinson, WI, is this high-end diner that serves excellent quality food and drinks.
Fort Atkinson Family Restaurant is a family-run restaurant with an upscale and cordial ambiance. When you step in, you would expect a simple menu, but it is large and contains your favorites.
To warm up your day, you should taste chicken dumpling soup or beef noodles. Lingonberry Swedish pancakes with blueberries and bananas are another best bet on the menu. Next, order a soft drink or coffee to combine with your food or sip it slowly.
Come on weekends or evenings and experience the taste of the neighborhood in a plate of your favorite. Even though the place can be pretty busy, service is usually prompt and fast.
Fort Atkinson Family Restaurant is open on Sunday to Tuesday, from 5 am – 3 pm, and Wednesday to Saturday, from 5 am – 9 pm.
Address: 1620 Janesville Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538-2726. Phone: +1 920-563-6324
Plan a Trip to Fort Atkinson
You must have had a tremendous treat already, so why not make Fort Atkinson your next visit? You’ll have every reason to do that.
The food scene comprises extensive options to stimulate your taste bud and give you the uttermost satisfaction your desire.
Hopefully, any of the above will provide the best dishes you crave.