15 Best Restaurants in Fairplay (CO)

Fairplay is a small town in Colorado, USA’s central mountains. With a population of approximately 700 people, it offers a variety of outdoor recreational activities, cultural events, and community gatherings for visitors and locals alike.

In addition to its natural attractions, Fairplay also boasts a rich cultural heritage. Visitors can explore the town’s many historic buildings and museums, which showcase the area’s mining and pioneer history.

Fairplay is a must-visit destination for anyone traveling to the central mountains of Colorado. Despite its small size, it boasts an impressive array of dining options that will tantalize your taste buds and leave you craving more.

Visitors are offered exceptional service and quality meals at any of its restaurants. You can continue eating at Silver Scoop Creamery, Salado, Java Moose, Cahootz Cafe & Delicatessen, Sweet-Bakes Pantry, etc.

If you want to know more about the top restaurants in Fairplay, CO, do read on!

Best Restaurants in Fairplay

1. Silver Scoop Creamery

Silver Scoop Creamery

Do you love to have a quick taste of ice cream during work or on a hot afternoon? Then consider Silver Scoop Creamery in Fairplay, CO, your best spot.

This lively restaurant is a great place to indulge in a sweet treat while enjoying the scenic beauty of Fairplay, Colorado.

The restaurant has a friendly and welcoming atmosphere, making it a popular spot for families, friends, and tourists visiting the area to taste their delicious ice cream.

Seating, outdoor seating, and takeout are some of their enticing features, and the facility is wheelchair accessible.

Some of the most popular flavors at Silver Scoop Creamery include Mint Chocolate Chip, Strawberry Cheesecake, Peanut Butter Cup, and a variety of hand-crafted ice cream flavors, sundaes, and other sweet treats.

You can visit them Mondays to Saturdays from 10:00 am to 04:30 pm and Sundays from 11:00 am to 04:30 pm.

Address: 456 Front St., Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-3403

2. Salado


Salado is next on our list of top restaurants in Fairplay, CO, and it is also worth visiting,

The restaurant offers a diverse menu featuring Southwestern and Mexican cuisine cooked from scratch to satisfy everyone’s palate.

The atmosphere of this restaurant is cozy and rustic, with wooden tables, chairs, and a fireplace in the dining area. They are also known for their friendly and attentive service that will make you return for a second dining experience.

Their excellent features include reservations, takeout, credit cards, table service, etc. The facility is also wheelchair accessible.

The delectable popular dishes on their menu include enchiladas, burritos, tacos, and fajitas. They also offer a range of vegetarian options, including tofu tacos and vegetarian burritos. Interestingly, there is a bar area where customers can enjoy drinks and cocktails.

Salado is open for business Mondays, Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays from 04:00 to 09:00 pm. They are closed on Tuesdays and Wednesdays.

Address: 456 Front St Suite B, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-7031

3. Java Moose

Java Moose

One of the best places to eat in Fairplay, CO, is Java Moose which is worth visiting.

Java Moose in Fairplay, CO, is a great spot known for its delicious meals and coffee in a welcoming atmosphere.

The atmosphere at this stunning dining place is cozy and welcoming, with comfortable seating and free Wi-Fi for customers who want to work or study while they enjoy their coffee or food. There is indeed a great advantage for remote workers in this restaurant.

The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about the coffee and food offerings, and they are happy to help customers choose the perfect drink or meal for their taste preferences.

When you dine here, you will enjoy their unique features, including takeout, free wifi, seating, and gift cards. More so, the facility is wheelchair accessible.

In addition to coffee, their menu includes breakfast items like bagels, breakfast burritos, oatmeal, sandwiches, salads, and soups for lunch.

They are always available Mondays to Sundays from 07:00 am to 02:00 pm.

Address: 730 Main Street, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-0770

4. Millonzi’s Restaurant

Millonzi’s Restaurant

Another fantastic restaurant on our top list is Millonzi’s Restaurant.

This beautiful restaurant offers delicious Italian food in a charming mountain town setting.

The restaurant has a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, rustic décor, and comfortable seating. It also has indoor and outdoor seating options, and the outdoor patio has beautiful views of the surrounding mountains.

The staff is friendly, and they serve food in a friendly and pleasant manner to diners.

Outdoor seating, street parking, seating, table service, highchair availability, etc., are some of the charming features of this restaurant. The facility is wheelchair accessible, too.

In addition to its Italian cuisine, Millonzi’s offers a selection of burgers, sandwiches, salads, and soups. They have a full bar with various wines, beers, and cocktails.

You can visit them Wednesday to Sunday from 04:00 pm to 09:00 pm.

Address: 501 Front St., Fairplay, CO 80440-5001, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-9501

5. Soup Pot

Soup Pot

Next on this list of the best restaurants in Fairplay, CO, is Soup Pot, and it is also worth visiting.

This restaurant specializes in serving a variety of soups, sandwiches, and salads.

They serve high-quality food in a welcoming setting. Their menu offers a variety of delectable meals to suit your taste, their staff is kind and accommodating, and their environment is ideal in every way.

Some of their admirable features include seating, takeout, and wheelchair accessibility.

You will be delighted when you taste their most popular soup offerings, which include creamy tomato basil, chicken noodle, and chili. They also offer a variety of sandwiches and salads with fresh ingredients.

Soup Pot is always open for business Mondays to Saturdays from 11:00 am to 06:00 pm.

Address: 331 US Hwy 285 Unit C, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-838-3543

6. Asian Fusion

Asian Fusion

This charming restaurant combines various Asian cuisine from different Asian cultures and creates new and unique dishes that blend flavors, ingredients, and cooking styles.

This dining establishment offers meals at affordable pricing, and its fast and friendly services make it a must-stop for tourists and locals alike, in addition to its cozy atmosphere pleasant, relaxing environment, and fast service.

Some of their enticing features include table service, seating, serving alcohol, and takeout.

Some everyday dishes on their menus include sushi rolls, dumplings, stir-fried noodles or rice, curries, and various meat or seafood dishes. The menu also includes vegetarian or vegan options and gluten-free choices.

You can visit them Mondays to Sundays from 11:00 am to 08:30 pm.

Address: 22186 US Highway 285, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-4468

7. McCall’s Park Bar

McCall’s Park Bar

McCall’s Park Bar is an amazing restaurant that is worth adding to your list of the best restaurants in Fairplay, CO,

This family-friendly establishment offers a casual dining experience in a cozy and comfortable atmosphere.

The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating options, and it’s a great place to stop by for a quick lunch or dinner while exploring the town or outdoor activities in the nearby mountains.

They are also known for their friendly and welcoming staff, who provide excellent customer service. Their live music performances on select nights also add to the lively and enjoyable ambiance of the restaurant.

Full bar, seating, outdoor seating, serving alcohol, takeout, etc., are some advantages you will benefit from when you come to this restaurant. In addition, their facility is wheelchair accessible.

The restaurant serves various American cuisine, including burgers, sandwiches, salads, and comfort food favorites such as mac and cheese, chicken and waffles, and meatloaf. They also offer a variety of wines and cocktails to complement their food menu.

McCall’s Park Bar is one of the best restaurants in this city, and it is open Sundays to Fridays from 11:00 am to 02:00 am and Saturdays from 11:00 am to 01:30 am.

Address: 511 Front Street, Fairplay, CO, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-3404

8. Platte River Salon

Platte River Salon

Feel free to add Platte River Salon to the list of top restaurants to sate your appetite in Fairplay, CO.

This beautiful restaurant offers a unique dining experience with stunning views of nature and delicious food, making it an excellent destination for anyone visiting Fairplay, Colorado.

Diners feel relaxed by its rustic and charming atmosphere reflecting the region’s history and scenic view of the mountains and countryside. Their kind and accommodating staff will turn you into a regular diner.

Also, diners who enjoy a good music vibe can get a spot at the bar and listen to live performances in this restaurant.

Their mouthwatering menu includes burgers, sandwiches, salads, and entrees like steak, fish, and chicken. They also have a selection of appetizers and desserts. The restaurant uses fresh and locally sourced ingredients whenever possible.

You can come here Mondays to Sundays from 11:00 am to 12:00 am.

Address: 517 Front Street, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-3461.

Want to know more places to eat in Colorado? Here is a guide on restaurants in Five Points Denverrestaurants in Keystone, and restaurants in Silverthorne for a fun meal time.

9. Casa Sanchez 4

Casa Sanchez 4

Do you adore Mexican cuisine? Casa Sanchez 4 has something that will delight your palate.

This charming restaurant specializes in outstanding Mexican cuisine and has been a popular destination for locals and visitors.

The restaurant has a casual and cozy atmosphere, with indoor and outdoor seating options for a quick lunch, family dinner, or a night out with a friend. You will love the staff of this restaurant due to their prompt service.

Some of their popular dishes include fajitas, enchiladas, tacos, burritos, and quesadillas. They also offer vegetarian and gluten-free options.

In addition to their food menu, they have a full bar that serves a range of alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, including margaritas, beer, wine, and soda.

Will you love to be here? They are always open Mondays to Sundays from 10:30 am to 09:00 pm.

Address: 706 Main St, Fairplay, CO 80440-5278, USA. Phone: +1 719-838-4229

10. KB’s Kabery & Dorothys Tamales

KB’s Kabery & Dorothys Tamales

This Mexican restaurant specializes in homemade tamales and has existed for over 30 years.

This restaurant’s welcoming and friendly environment and small dining area make it a popular spot for locals and tourists.

Diners who visit here enjoy their superb meals at reasonable prices in a comfortable and welcoming ambiance and order takeout or delivery for a simple dinner at home.

Do you love to go out with your pet? This pet-friendly restaurant makes your pet feel comfortable while you enjoy your delicious meal.

Free Wi-Fi, accepting credit cards, highchair availability, serving alcohol, outdoor seating, and takeout are some of the enticing features. The facility is wheelchair accessible.

In addition to tamales, the restaurant also serves other Mexican dishes such as tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and quesadillas. Customers can choose from various fillings for their tamales, including pork, chicken, beef, and vegetarian options.

You can visit them Mondays to Sundays from 07:00 am to 04:00 pm.

Address: 331 US Highway 285 Unit A, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-838-2533

11. Cahootz Café & Delicatessen

Cahootz Café & Delicatessen

Amongst the top restaurants in Fairplay, CO, Cahootz Café & Delicatessen is a notable one worth visiting.

As the name suggests, this restaurant offers a variety of food and drink options in a cozy and charming setting.

Cahootz Café & Delicatessen has a cozy and welcoming atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. The décor is rustic and charming, with wooden tables, chairs, and wall artwork.

Their customers are treated warmly and welcomed by their friendly and attentive staff. Its meals are excellent, with generous portions at an affordable price.

This restaurant’s unique features that amaze diners include Seating, outdoor table service, takeout, etc.

They offer a range of food menus, including breakfast dishes, sandwiches, salads, soups, and desserts. They also have vegetarian and gluten-free options for diners on a special diet.

Cahootz Café & Delicatessen is open Mondays to Thursdays from 11:00 am to 06:30 pm and Fridays to Saturdays from 11:00 am to 07:00 pm.

Address: 640 Highway 285 Unit B in Sinclair Plaza, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-838-5140

12. Sweet-Bakes Pantry

Sweet-Bakes Pantry

This list of best Fairplay restaurants, will not be complete without adding Sweet-Bakes Pantry.

Sweet-Bakes Pantry is a cozy and welcoming restaurant serving delicious baked goods, breakfast items, and sandwiches.

This classic dining place uses only locally and organically sourced ingredients to make its dishes. They provide dependable and friendly service to all diners. When you walk in here to eat, you will get more than enough satisfaction, leaving your taste buds craving more.

Their delivery and takeout option is a feature their regular diners admire. You can order your favorite dishes and deliver them to your preferred location. Diners who prefer dining at the restaurant can relax on their lovely seating arrangements.

They also offer a variety of breakfast items, including pancakes, waffles, and breakfast sandwiches. Don’t forget to order Sweet-Bakes Pantry’s salads and soups for lunch, and you won’t regret the simmering taste it will leave on your tastebuds.

Sweet-Bakes Pantry is open for business Wednesdays to Saturdays from 08:00 am to 04:00 pm.

Address: 526 Front Street, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 970-389-5886

13. Mr. Burro Café

Mr. Burro Café

Also worth adding to your list of best Fairplay restaurants is Mr. Burro Café restaurant.

Mr. Burro Café is popular among locals and tourists and known for its delicious authentic Mexican food and welcoming atmosphere.

The restaurant has a casual and cozy atmosphere, with indoor and outdoor seating available. Customers can enjoy their meals in a relaxed environment, with friendly service provided by the staff.

In addition to dining in, the restaurant offers takeout and delivery to their customers.

Customers can expect fresh and authentic Mexican food made with high-quality ingredients on their menu, including tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and other traditional dishes. The menu also offers vegetarian and gluten-free options.

Mr. Burro Café opens Mondays to Saturdays from 07:00 am to 05:00 pm and Sundays from 09:00 am to 05:00 pm.

Address: 702 Main St, Fairplay, CO 80440, USA. Phone: +1 719-837-2028

14. South Park Saloon

South Park Saloon

Among the top Fairplay restaurants is South Park Saloon and it should be added to your list of places to eat while you are in the area.

South Park Saloon is 5.4 miles from Fairplay, CO. It is a popular dining and entertainment destination for locals and visitors.

The restaurant has a casual atmosphere with Western-themed décor, including a large wooden bar, cowboy hats, and rustic furnishings. Their staffs are amicable, and dinners are always served quickly in a friendly, cozy atmosphere.

In addition to its food and drink offerings, the South Park Saloon hosts live music events on weekends, adding to the entertainment value of the restaurant.

Table service, a full bar, seating, parking availability, etc., are some excellent features the restaurant offers its customers. The facility is wheelchair accessible.

They offer various food options, from burgers, sandwiches, and salads to steaks and seafood. They also provide a selection of beer, wine, and cocktails to accompany your meal.

South Park Saloon is one of the best restaurants, and it is always open Mondays to Fridays from 11:00 am to 11:00 pm and Saturdays to Sundays from 07:00 am to 11:00 pm.

Address: 24 N Main St, Alma, CO 80420, USA. Phone: +1 719-836-2762

15. Otto’s Food Cart

Otto’s Food Cart

Concluding this list of best places to eat in Fairplay, CO, is Otto’s Food Cart which is also worth visiting.

This restaurant is known for its delicious food, friendly service, and laid-back atmosphere.

Diners who come here frequently are welcomed in a warm atmosphere with a view of the surrounding mountains and beautiful scenery. Their commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients adds to the quality and flavor of their food, along with exceptional services.

One of the notable features of this restaurant is that they offer takeout.

The menu features a range of tasty dishes, including sandwiches, burgers, salads, and more. Some of the most popular items on the menu include the Philly cheesesteak sandwich, the elk burger, and the fish tacos. They also offer vegetarian and gluten-free options.

You can visit them Mondays to Sundays from 08:00 am to 08:00 pm.

Address: 45 S Main St, Alma, CO 80420-5074, USA. Phone: +1 719-839-8276.

Also, check out our guide on restaurants in Grand Junction, restaurants in Fort Morgan, and restaurants in South Fork for a memorable meal time in Colorado.

Plan a Trip to Fairplay

Fairplay, Colorado, is a prime spot for an unforgettable escape due to its captivating landscape and rich history.

Not only that, food enthusiasts find Fairplay a destination of choice for more than just its cuisine; the inviting ambiance of the fine dining options, coupled with the warm and enthusiastic hospitality of the staff, offers a pleasing dining experience.

Whether you crave a rich breakfast to power your day exploration or a romantic dinner for two, Fairplay’s diverse food scene caters to all tastes.

Start planning a getaway to Fairplay, CO, and be ready to enjoy the local fare and savor the dishes it has to offer.