15 Best Restaurants in Buckeye Lake (OH)

If you are searching for the best restaurants in Buckeye Lake, Ohio, then you are in the right place.

Buckeye Lake is Ohio’s oldest state park built in 1826 as a feeder lake for a canal and is characterized by countless chances for water-related leisure like swimming, skiing, boating, and fishing.

When Buckeye Lake first began, it was a tiny pond that Ohio Indians called “Big Swamp” or “Big Pond” in the eighteenth century and approximately 15 years before Ohio became a state, in 1788, the word “Buckeye” was initially used to describe a local person.

Ohio’s Fairfield, Licking, and Perry counties contain the reservoir known as Buckeye Lake. The use of the lake changed to recreation after the canal system was abandoned in the early 20th century.

The park has long been a well-liked vacation destination and a top-rated tourist attraction site.

This guide has collected the best restaurants in Buckeye Lake, Ohio. Here is a list of the top restaurants in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.

Best Restaurants in Buckeye Lake

1 Pizza Cottage

Pizza Cottage

The first Pizza Cottage was established in Carroll, Ohio when Jack and Yvonne Gorham transformed it into a small Coney store now run by their son Kevin.

The restaurant holds by the principle to always use the best ingredients and give back to the community.

The restaurant is known for its upbeat and attentive staff, which attests to a part of their values which states that customers must be treated as nothing less than family.

Patrons are comfortable in outdoor seating overlooking the bustling Buckeye Lake, and Pizza Cottage also offers curbside pick-up and dine-in services.

The menu features Classic dishes such as fried mozzarella, garlic bread with cheese, jalapeno peppers, and fried pickle chips. Traditional and boneless chicken tenders are served with hot and mild sauces.

Pizza Cottage opens on Sundays to Thursdays from 11:00 am-10:00 pm and Fridays to Saturdays from 11:00 am-11:00 pm.

Address: 4592 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008. Phone: +1 740-928-1144.

2. Our Lakeside Diner

Our Lakeside Diner

If you are on the lookout for a place with a great selection of desserts and the perfect service to go with, you need not search further than Our Lakeside Diner, one of the best Buckeye Lake restaurants.

This Buckeye Lake restaurant combines the love for making delectable food with an in-depth understanding of the culinary methods to make unique dishes solely for the pleasure and satisfaction of their patrons.

The charming eatery offers an outdoor patio that overlooks the picturesque view of Heart River, wheelchair-accessible facilities, and other full-service options such as a kids’ menu, quick bites, small plates, and comfort food.

A la carte dishes such as corn beef hash, and English muffins, bagels with butter or cream cheese are featured on the menu.

The restaurant welcomes all patrons on Sundays and Saturdays from 7:00 am-2:00 pm, Mondays to Thursdays from 8:00 am-2:00 pm, and Fridays from 8:00 am-6:00 pm.

Address: 5276 Walnut Rd SE, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008-7872. Phone: +1 740-928-4062.

3. Chef Shack

Chef Shack

John and Kim Stedman own Chef Shack and are dedicated to serving their customers a little bit and more of everything in a homely and casual ambiance to ensure they leave the door with glad hearts and satisfied stomachs.

The diner blends classic American cuisine with a frequently rotated menu to aid diversity. It is worthy of note that reasonably priced meals are served in generous portions.

Customer service is a top priority in the establishment. Another great thing is its devotion to using freshly sourced ingredients for all dishes, supporting local farmers in the region.

Popular meals on the menu include Cajun shrimp pasta, chicken salad, pulled pork sandwich, jambalaya, and Korean BBQ tacos.

Visit Chef Shack Mondays to Thursdays from 4:00 pm-9:00 pm, Fridays from 11:00 am-9:00 pm, and Saturdays from 11:00 am-6:00 pm.

Address: 5176 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008-7790. Phone: +1 740-527-2947.

4. Buckeye Lake Brewery

Buckeye Lake Brewery

Since opening its doors in 2016, Buckeye Lake Brewery has grown to become a well-loved spot for locals and one of the top restaurants in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.

Locals visit this restaurant to enjoy quality beer ranging from light and refreshing lagers in a charming and welcoming atmosphere.

The beers served in the brewery have a distinctive taste as they are brewed with hops from Ohio and fresh fruits and vegetables obtained in collaboration with local farmers.

Besides the excellent beer offered at the establishment, the menu features a variety of appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and entrees.

Enjoy meals such as chicken, shrimp, caramelized onion chive dips, jambalaya, the signature brewery burger made with Ohio-raised beef, and tacos featuring locally caught perch fillets.

Visit the brewery on Sundays and Saturdays from 1:00 pm-11:00 pm and Mondays to Fridays from 4:00 pm-10:00 pm.

Address: 5176 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008-7790. Phone: +1 740-535-6225

5. Dragon Village

Dragon Village

Dragon Village is renowned for providing the Buckeye Lake populace with delectable and reasonably priced authentic Chinese cuisine.

Classic Chinese elements like lanterns and dragon motifs decorate the walls of the restaurant, giving it a basic yet elegant decor, and the comfortable seating arrangement is ideal for both small-group gatherings and big ones.

The restaurant provides wheelchair-accessible facilities, high chairs, and seating and is the ideal environment for kids.

Appetizers such as shrimp rolls, fried dumplings, teriyaki beef or chicken, fried wonton, and doughnuts and soups, which include chicken noodles, vegetable and bean curd, and egg drop soup, are offered at the establishment.

Dragon Village opens on Sundays from 12:00 pm-9:00 pm, Tuesdays to Thursdays from 11:00 pm-9:00 pm, and Fridays and Saturdays from 11:00 am-9:30 pm.

Address: 11097 Hebron Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008-7710. Phone: +1 740-928-6800

6. Donatos Pizza

Donatos Pizza

Next on this list of best restaurants in Buckeye Lake, Ohio is Donatos Pizza.

The unique name, “Donatos,” stems from a Latin word that means to give a new thing; this chain of pizza restaurants since the 1960s has attested to the semantics ever since.

The interior decor of the establishment is made up of walls adorned in pizza-related designs and a warm and inviting atmosphere topped with friendly and attentive staff.

Donatos Pizza offers services such as outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, take away and dine-in to aid convenience for their patrons.

Start your meals with Italian breadsticks dipped in marinara sauce or boneless all white chicken meat served with the signature Donatos sauce. Fill your stomachs with desserts that include a cinnamon twist, a chocolate chunk cookie, and the apple crisp timpani.

Donatos Pizza welcomes everyone every day from 11:00 am-10:00 pm.

Address: 11048 Hebron Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008. Phone: +1 740-928-7174.

7. Subway


Subway, founded in 1965, is a well-known fast food company specializing in submarine sandwiches, otherwise known as “subs,” and has since expanded to a global brand with thousands of locations worldwide.

Customers can alter their orders with various toppings and condiments at Subway, and the menu usually has choices for vegetarians and meat eaters.

The establishment offers an ideal environment for kids with high chairs and toilets and other service options such as kerbside pick-up, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in.

Their menu includes a juicy rotisserie-style chicken, chicken and bacon ranch, buffalo chicken topped with peppercorn ranch, oven-roasted turkey and ham, meatball marinara sandwich, tuna, and classic sandwiches.

Visit Subway from 8:30 am-9:30 pm on Mondays through Sundays. It is is one of the best places to eat in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.

Address: 4675 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008-7770. Phone: +1 740-527-2343

8. Taco Bell

Taco Bell

Whether you are craving a traditional classic taco or something a little more novel, Taco Bell has a diverse menu featuring delectable repasts to appease your hunger.

The restaurant started serving tacos in its first location in 1962 in California and was formerly known as Glen Bell up to date is popular among customers as a brand that offers the most satisfying and affordable Mexican-inspired meals.

Taco Bell, with its charming interior and friendly staff, is committed to ensuring all patrons enjoy an excellent dining experience.

Try the Chalupa Supreme made of perfectly tempered beef, lettuce, tomatoes, and sour cream, and you will have nothing short of a rapture of delight on your tastebuds.

Taco Bell opens on Sundays to Wednesdays from 9:00 am-12:00 am and Fridays to Saturdays from 9:00 am-1:00 am.

Address: 10800 Hebron Road SE, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008. Phone: +1 740-928-2568.

Planning a food tour of Ohio? Here is a guide on restaurants in Canal Winchester, restaurants in Loveland, and restaurants in Marysville for a fun meal time.

9. McDonald’s


With more than 39,000 locations across over a hundred countries, McDonald’s is one of the biggest fast-food chains globally known for its iconic menu items, such as the Big Mac.

Since its establishment in 1940, it has become a worldwide phenomenon and is also among the best restaurants in Buckeye Lake, Ohio.

Thanks to its standardized menu and operational practices, McDonald’s has a reputation for reliability and effectiveness that aims to give customers a quick and efficient dining experience.

The restaurant offers full-service options such as curbside pick-up, delivery, drive-through, takeaway, and dine-in.

Placate your sweet tooth by ordering flavored milkshakes, vanilla cones, hot fudge sundaes, and perfectly baked cookies such as chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin.

Visit McDonald’s on Sundays from 7:00 am-11:00 pm and every other day from 6:00 am-11:00 pm.

Address: I-70 & Rt 79, Buckeye Lake, OH 43025. Phone: +1 740-929-1690.

10. Beach House Pub

Beach House Pub

Whether you’re craving a cold beer on a hot day or a chic cocktail to sip while taking in the twilight, Beach House Pub offers something for everyone.

The destination is renowned in the Buckeye Lake area for its fantastic customer service with its attentive staff and a myriad of fun activities to enjoy with friends and loved ones, such as karaoke, sport, quiz nights, and live music.

The tavern, close to the lake, provides breathtaking water views and a relaxed setting ideal for unwinding with friends and family, this makes it one of the best Buckeye Lake restaurants.

The Beach House Pub is known for its wide variety of cuisine, which ranges from traditional burgers and fries to seafood selections like fish and chips and shrimp cocktails.

The establishment opens on Saturdays to Sundays from 12:00 pm-2:30 am and Mondays to Thursdays from 11:00 am-2:30 am.

Address: 13574 Shell Beach Rd NE, Thornville, OH 43076-9172. Phone: +1 740-467-7180

11. Papa Boo’s

Papa Boo's

Papa Boo is a popular café situated on a waterfront property with a picturesque view of the lake, fantastic food, and a lively atmosphere and has been a well-loved destination over the years for residents and locals alike.

The restaurant features both outdoor and indoor seating options in which; the former includes enjoying the warm weather on the patio with live music, and the latter for dining in the cozy interior.

Meals such as burgers, great pizza, zucchini fries, onion rings, shrimp pizza, steak wrap, coconut shrimp, fish and chips, taco pizza, and loaded tater tots are available.

Fresh salads and frozen drinks such as margaritas, strawberry daiquiri, pina colada, wine, and sangria are also served at the restaurant.

Visit Papa Boo’s on Sundays from 11:00 am-9:00 pm, Wednesdays to Fridays from 4:00 pm-9:00 pm, and Saturdays from 11:00 am-11:00 pm.

Address: 11356 Avondale Rd, Thornville, OH 43076-9339. Phone: +1 740-928-2667.

12. Mill Dam Corner Grill

Mill Dam Corner Grill

Patrons desiring excellent food service, delicious food, and a great atmosphere need not look further than Mill Dam Corner Grill.

The restaurant’s interior décor is cozy and rustic, with masonry walls and wooden accentuations, giving it a warm and inviting ambiance.

The selection at Mill Dam Corner Grill is extensive, providing a range of choices to accommodate various tastes and dietary requirements. Burgers from the eatery are well-known for being made with premium ingredients and perfectly cooked.

The pizzas are stone baked and served with toppings according to your picks, such as pineapples, tomatoes, green peppers, jalapenos, and mushrooms.

You can visit this restaurant every day from 7:00 am-2:30 am and on Sundays from 8:00 am-2:30 am.

Address: 3982 National Rd SE, Hebron, OH 43025-9547. Phone: +1 740-928-3567

13. Bob Evans

Bob Evans

When Bob Evans opened its doors in 1965, it rapidly gained popularity as a place for families and road trippers to stop and eat. Originally a tiny 60-seat diner, the restaurant enlarged as its clientele increased.

Diners can savor delicious traditional American comfort cuisine while taking in stunning water views and enjoying a cup of the delicious coffee served at the restaurant.

Bob Evans offers service options such as curbside pick-up, takeaway, dine-in, and wheelchair-accessible facilities.

Enjoy steak and eggs benedict, pot roast beef dinner, baked potato soup, honey butter chicken and biscuit, chicken pot pie, and flounder fillets.

Everyone is welcome to Bob Evans every day from 10:00 am-8:00 pm except on Sundays and Saturdays from 8:00 am-8:00 pm.

Address: 10679 Lancaster Rd Inside Travel America, Hebron, OH 43025. Phone: +1 740-467-2288

14. Island House

Island House

Island House, first constructed in the late 1800s, has experienced numerous renovations but has kept its vintage allure and personality.

The restaurant provides fantastic dining choices and various entertainment options, such as a marina where guests can hire jet skis and a private beach where guests can enjoy swimming, sunbathing, and water sports.

Weddings and corporate events are frequently held at this famous location. It is an ideal option for any special occasion, thanks to its lovely setting, elegant architecture, and first-rate amenities.

The menu offers jalapeno pretzels, fried green tomatoes, coleslaw, soft tacos, crab cakes, and the signature Island cheeseburger.

Island House welcomes patrons every day from 11:00 am-1:00 pm and is also worth adding to your list of top Buckeye Lake restaurants

Address: 2977 Greenlawn Ave NE, Millersport, OH 43046-8011. Phone: +1 740-467-2035.

15. Sbarro


Sbarro is an Italian fast-food franchise founded in 1956 by Carmela and Gennaro. It initially started as a grocery shop that offered Italian goods such as cheese and cured meats; however, three years later, the owners established the first pizza place adjacent to the store.

The full-service restaurant offers a salad bar, organic dishes, quick bites, outdoor seating, delivery, and wheelchair-accessible facilities and accepts reservations.

The menu includes many pizza and pasta options, salads, stromboli, and other classic Italian snacks and sides.

Enjoy popular meals such as seasoned spinach and marinated mushrooms, melted mozzarella and plum tomato sauce, pasta with meatballs, chicken wings, and pepperoni stromboli.

Sbarro welcomes guests every day from 10:00 am-10:00 pm.

Address: 10679 Lancaster Rd., Hebron, OH 43025. Phone: +1 740-467-2900.

Also check out our guide on restaurants in Mount Vernon, restaurants in Rocky River, and restaurants in Strongsville for a fun meal time in Ohio.

Plan a trip to Buckeye Lake

Taking time off to travel and visit new places makes one happier and less stressed as it means trying new meals, seeing culture and traditions through a different outlook, and making memories that last a lifetime.

Good food is one of the most contingent factors that influences a good getaway, and Buckeye Lake has more than enough establishments offering it; pack your bags and do well to enjoy your trip.