15 Best Restaurants in Big Pine Key (FL)

Big Pine Key is an unincorporated village and a census-designated place in Monroe County, Florida, in the United States.

The island is most popular because it is home to the key deer, a subspecies of white-tailed deer that live in a protected environment.

With a population of about 5,032 people, Big Pine Key provides enjoyable activities such as fishing, kayaking, and bird-watching.

Food in Big Pine Key is a diverse and exciting subject. The diversity of food in this village reflects the diversity of the people who live there.

Big Pine Key boasts a surprising number of restaurants for a small town. You’re likely to find something to your taste, whether you’re in the mood for seafood, Mexican, Italian, or just an excellent ol’ burger.

This guide has collected the best places to eat in Big Pine Key, FL. Here are the top restaurants in Big Pine Key, FL.

Best Restaurants in Big Pine Key

1. Big Pine Rooster

Big Pine Rooster

Big Pine Rooster, also known as BPR, is more than just a restaurant; it is a significant element of a genuinely excellent neighborhood.

They use the most up-to-date technologies to expedite order processing and deliver the best service. Big Pine Rooster identifies as women-owned and offers dine-in, delivery, and takeout options and provides outdoor seating for guests.

There is no denying that the cuisine at Big Pine Rooster is among the best in the area. Every meal the chefs here produce reflects their genuine love for cooking.

The menu offers a wide range of dishes, all prepared with fresh, regional ingredients. The starters are perfect, with pan-fried calamari and roasted beet salad sticking out. Everything from wood-fired pizzas to chicken pot pie is available as the main meal.

And, of course, a meal wouldn’t be complete without one of their delectable dessert options.

They operate daily from 9 am to 9 pm.

Address: 29943 Overseas Hwy, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-330-1330.

2. Good Food Conspiracy

Good Food Conspiracy

A grocery shop, deli, juice bar, and organic health food market are all part of Good Food Conspiracy. Good Food has been energizing clients for more than 40 years since it was founded in 1982 by Marney Brown.

Along the walls are an extensive range of vitamins, supplements, and herbs. Various types of dried fruits, nuts, and healthful cold beverages are all included in the refrigerators, along with snacks and meals.

This company provides a curbside pickup for convenience, an in-store pickup and in-store shopping.

A great selection of delicious, freshly made organic juices, fruit smoothies, vegan and vegetarian sandwiches, including the renowned pescatarian tuna everything sandwich, daily homemade soups, vegan cookies, and raw and baked desserts are available at Good Food.

They are open from 10 am to 6 pm on Mondays to Saturdays.

Address: 30150 Overseas Hwy, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-3945.

3. No Name Pub

No Name Pub

No Name Pub, one of the top Big Pine Key restaurants has a long history, beginning in 1931 when it was a general store and bait and tackle shop.

Before the owners of this Big Pine Key restaurant added a small room to the main building to turn it into a restaurant in 1936, the establishment remained as it was. This was when the Pub was created.

Nothing compares to sipping a refreshing beer in the outdoor area of No Name Pub on a hot day. With lots of room to stretch out and various seating options, this is a terrific spot to relax with friends and take advantage of the weather.

You can also dine indoors if you want or settle for the takeout option; this establishment still provides the best services either way.

No Name Pub received the ZAGAT’s top rating for the “Best casual dining experience in the Florida Keys” after a survey of more than 700 South Florida eateries.

Their menu options range from house-made sangria, smoked fish dip, key lime pie, conch fritters, coconut shrimp, and tacos to lobster bisque, fried grouper basket, Cuban sandwich, calzones, meathead pizza, and veggie salad.

No Name operates from 11 am to 10 pm daily.

Address: 30813 Watson Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-9115.

4. Paradise BSB

Paradise BSB

Paradise BSB is a restaurant like no other. Located in the heart of downtown Los Angeles, Paradise BSB overlooks the city skyline and offers a menu of American classics with a twist.

This restaurant is the ideal location whether you’re searching for a venue to enjoy a special occasion with friends or a romantic supper. Your evening will be remembered thanks to the breathtaking surroundings, first-rate cuisine, and beautifully made beverages.

Twenty televisions and 16 taps of beer are available to enjoy your preferred sporting event. This eatery also features a lively environment, wheelchair-accessible services, and takeout options and serves the best gourmet burgers, outstanding pizzas, and salads.

The roasted chicken with superb cornbread stuffing and the Gulf shrimp and grits, both of which are prepared with smoky bacon, stand out among the menu items.

With only the freshest ingredients, bartenders are masters at creating unique beverages. Paradise Punch, grapefruit juice-based drink, and the Southern Belle, a bourbon, sweet tea, and lemon-based cocktail, are standouts on the cocktail menu.

Opening hours are on Tuesdays to Saturdays from 11 am to 9 pm.

Address: 31251 Ave A, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-998-4196.

5. Trianos Taco Company

Coco’s Kitchen

One of the top restaurants in Big Pine Key, FL is Trianos Taco Company. In addition to a complete bar and a large selection of beers and wines, this restaurant serves various delectable cuisine with Mexican influences.

They provide a take-out menu, and if you’re looking for vegetarian and vegan options, there are plenty of delicious and healthy choices, like the black bean soup, a vegan ranchero, or the house salad.

The menu features shrimp tacos, enchiladas, shredded spicy chicken, queso fresco, burritos, rice bowl, ground beef, pico de galio, jalapenos, shrimp salad, and nachos. They also provide a variety of soups, salads, and sides.

They are open from 11 am to 5 pm, Mondays through Thursdays.

Address: 30770 Overseas Hwy, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 816-377-3572.

6. Coco’s Kitchen

Coco’s Kitchen

Coco’s Kitchen is a family-run Mexican eatery and adds as one of the best Big Pine Key restaurants. Since it opened more than 20 years ago, the restaurant has become renowned for some of the best food and rates.

Reservations are not required but are recommended for parties of six or more, so if you’re looking for a delicious, authentic Cuban meal in Big Key Pine, Coco’s Kitchen is the place to go. This little cantina also allows customers to take their food on the go with the takeout option.

There are many Cuban-inspired foods available at Coco’s Kitchen, such as roast pork prepared in the style of Cuba, Cuban sandwiches, plantain chips, and black beans prepared in the manner of Cuba.

Cocktails with a Cuban influence, like the mojito and the Cuba Libre, are also available at the restaurant.

Coco’s Kitchen welcomes guests on Tuesdays to Saturdays from 7 am to 5 pm.

Address: 283 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-4495.

7. Island Pizza Company

Island Pizza Company

Island Pizza Company is a local favorite and one of the best places to eat in Big Key Pine, FL. The restaurant is family owned and operated and has served delicious pizzas, calzones, and more for over 20 years.

Fast, practical, and reasonably priced takeaway from Island Pizza Company makes it the ideal choice for busy families or anyone who prefers not to cook. This pizzeria is a takeout establishment and does not offer delivery and dine-in service options.

Pizzas, meatball subs, roasted pineapple ice cream, calzones, and other Italian favorites are available on the menu.

They are open Thursdays through Mondays from 4 pm to 9 pm.

Address: 30348 Overseas Hwy, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-7444.

8. Forks and Stix (Amazing rolls)

Forks and Stix (Amazing rolls)

Forks and Stix is a family-owned business that provides delicious rolls and other baked goods to the people of Big Pine Key, Florida. They offer dine-in, takeaway, and curbside delivery options.

This restaurant also provides organic dishes, vegetarian options, happy-hour drinks, small bites, and amenities such as wheelchair-accessible services, curbside pickup, and gender-neutral toilets.

Customers can access the company’s free Wi-Fi, as it is a great perk for those who need to stay connected while they eat. The Wi-Fi signal is robust and reliable so you can count on it for all your internet needs.

Forks and Stix offer credit and debit card payment options. If you have any questions regarding their payment options, don’t hesitate to ask one of the friendly staff members.

There are various kinds of rolls on the menu at Forks and Stix, including basic favorites like the classic cheese roll and more unusual varieties like the mango chicken roll.

Forks and Stix offers a wide range of menu options in addition to their amazing rolls, such as soups, salads, and sandwiches. Try one of the Forks and Stix’s desserts if you’re in the mood for something sweet like cakes, pies, and other sweets.

Operating hours are Tuesdays through Thursdays from 11 am to 7 pm, weekends from 11 am to 9 pm, and Sundays from 11 am to 4 pm.

Address: 30945 Ave A Unit A, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-680-9111.

Want to know more places to eat in Florida for fun dining? Check out our guide on restaurants in Lake Mary, restaurants in Ponce Inlet, and restaurants in Sebastian.

9. Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe

Bagel Island Sandwich Shoppe, one of the best restaurants in Big Pine Key, FL, is a locally owned and operated bagel shop specializing in made-to-order bagel sandwiches. They have an array of bagels to choose from, as well as an assortment of fresh toppings and spreads.

Bagel Island Sandwich lets patrons enjoy their tasty meals indoors or have them packaged as takeout.

Along with a selection of various kinds and specialties, Bagel Island serves authentic Cuban coffee and a choice of freshly baked bagels in a range of flavors.

The most popular varieties are plain, poppy seed, and everything, but the store also has a seasonal flavor menu that changes frequently.

The breakfast and lunch sandwiches are made with fresh bagels, deli meats, eggs, bacon, sausage, and cheeses and can be ordered with a side of chips or a salad.

Are you driving through the Florida Keys? Come in for lunch! Create your sandwich or try one of their specialty sandwiches.

They are open on Tuesdays to Thursdays from 7 am to 2 pm.

Address: 205 Key Deer Blvd, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-9912.

10. Boondocks Grille and Draft House

Boondocks Grille and Draft House

Boondocks Grille is one of the best Big Pine Key restaurants. It is known as the “Largest Tiki Bar in the Keys” and offers delicious cuisine and fun activities for the entire family, including pets.

Boondocks can accommodate parties of any size with its cutting-edge amenities, immaculate kitchen, cold prep area, and pet-friendly terrace. You can pay for the services at this establishment with debit or credit cards.

Boondocks live entertainment attracts residents and tourists to the patio for the best live music from both local and international artists, as well as state-of-the-art sound and lighting.

Some customers come here five days a week to eat at the outside restaurant because of Boondocks’ “Southern Cooking Keys Style.” This restaurant offers a wide variety of evening dishes and lunch sandwiches, as well as artisan-crafted pizzas, salads, burgers, and fresh seafood.

With the Boondocks Experience, servicing you is a breeze, and every day feels like a vacation.

They are open from 11 am to 10 pm daily.

Address: 27205 Overseas Hwy, Ramrod Key, FL 33042, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-4094.

11. Square Grouper Bar and Grill

Square Grouper Bar and Grill

With a focus on consistency and quality, Square Grouper Bar and Grill is one of the well-known and best restaurants in Big Pine Key, FL.

The Square Grouper Bar and Grill has been known as a must-visit restaurant thanks to Lynn and her staff’s commitment to excellence and attention to detail. The restaurant strongly emphasizes green, and all paper goods and straws are derived from maize.

Dining in at Square Grouper is an experience in itself, with the restaurant’s lush tropical setting and stunning views of the water. It is the perfect place to relax and escape the hustle and bustle of everyday life.

The takeout option is just as convenient because customers can order their favorite dishes and prepare them to eat on the go.

For a wide variety of creative small plates, regularly changing specials such as flash fried conch, sesame seared tuna, and fried green tomatoes handcrafted desserts, a boutique wine list, and a shifting range of microbrews, stop by Square Grouper Bar and Grill.

Opening hours are from 11 am to 2:30 pm and 5 pm to 10 pm on Tuesdays to Saturdays.

Address: 22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042, United States. Phone: +1 305-745-8880.

12. My New Joint

My New Joint

On Cudjoe Key, My New Joint is a cocktail lounge, tapas bar, and live music venue on the second floor of Square Grouper Bar and Grill.

They provide a Raw Bar with freshly shucked oysters from both the east and west coasts of the United States, a full liquor bar with a specialty cocktail menu, wines by the glass and bottle, 15 draft beers, a full tapas menu with salads and fondues, and lots of delicious desserts!

The items on the food menu include soft pretzels, Key Lime Pies, rare seared togarashi spiced tuna, grilled fresh oysters, fried banana split, roasted radishes, cauliflower au gratin, and flash-fried conch.

My New Joint’s staff always goes out of their way to be welcoming and accommodating, and they see you have a good time. They’re more than ready to provide suggestions if you’re unsure what you want and are always happy to answer any questions regarding the menu.

They operate Tuesdays through Saturdays from 4:20 pm to 11 pm.

Address: 22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042, United States. Phone: +1 305-745-8880.

13. Coconut Bar and Drive-Thru Liquor Store

Coconut Bar and Drive-Thru Liquor Store

One of the final top Big Pine Key restaurants is Coconuts Bar and Drive-Thru Liquor Store.

The Keys were significantly different back in 1983 when it was constructed. The establishment’s original owners are still in charge and are still involved in giving back to the neighborhood. Pine Key’s sole traffic light is where “Coconuts” is situated.

The outdoor seating at Coconut Bar is both comfortable and stylish. The chairs are well-padded, the umbrellas provide ample shade, and the breeze from the ocean is refreshing. Dining in is just as lovely, and if you are in a hurry, the takeout option is available.

The pub has a reputation for being welcoming and drawing in a wide variety of customers. The bar’s live performances, which frequently include regional bands, are also well-known.

Coconut Bar’s menu is filled with sumptuous delights like beef chili, suckling pig, and chili con carne.

Coconut Bar is open seven days a week from 7 am to 4 am.

Address: 30535 Overseas Hwy, Big Pine Key, FL 33043, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-3795.

14. Kiki’s Sandbar Bar and Grille

Kiki’s Sandbar Bar and Grille

Kiki’s Sandbar Bar and Grille is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family. The open-air setting is ideal for enjoying the Florida weather, and the views of the Gulf of Mexico are simply beautiful.

Kiki’s has a complete bar, as well as a selection of food and beverages. Favorites from the American comfort food scene are offered on the menu, including fish tacos, sandwiches, and sandbar salads. Kiki’s serves a variety of seafood dishes too, such as crab cakes and shrimp.

At Kiki’s Sandbar Beachfront Bar and Grille, enjoy delicious drinks, fresh seafood, and live music every night!

They are open from 11 am to 11 pm every day.

Address: 183 Barry Ave, Little Torch Key, FL 33042, United States. Phone: +1 305-872-4500.

15. The Dining Room

The Dining Room

Under the guidance of chef Louis Pous, the Dining Room at Little Palm Island tempts visitors with a flavorful fusion of French and Pan-Latin cuisine. This is one of the best restaurants in Big Pine Key, FL.

The best in fresh, regional cuisine is sampled on the always-changing menu. Meals can be taken in the exquisite dining room, which is lit by candles, on the terrace above the beach, where songbirds and key deer frequent, or at one of the many tables that are scattered along the shore.

Very few reservations from off the island are accepted in this restaurant’s dining room. Based on occupancy, this makes sure that visitors continue to enjoy the island’s exclusivity.

Dinner on the sand beneath the stars tonight seems like the perfect night. Or perhaps you like the luxury of the dining room’s internal air conditioning. In either case, you’ll be treated like royalty.

The Dining Room offers diver scallops, shrimp cocktail, key lime pie, pan-roasted filet mignon, and ceviche.

They are open daily from 8 am to 10:30 am, 11:30 am to 2:30 pm, and 6 pm to 10 pm, respectively.

Address: 28500 Overseas Hwy, Little Torch Key, FL 33042, United States. Phone: +1 305-422-4236.

Also Check out our guide on restaurants in Apalachicola, restaurants in Port Orange, and restaurants in Wilton Manors for a memorable meal time in Florida.

Plan a Trip to Big Pine Key

Foodies and visitors alike are becoming more and more interested in culinary tourism. It’s the ideal approach to combine your interests: delicious food and exotic locations.

Culinary travel is a fantastic way to experience a location, whether you’re arranging a vacation around a food festival or want to sample the local cuisine.

Big Pine Keg is just the perfect town for that. Plan a visit today!