15 Best Restaurants in Bayfield (WI)

Bayfield is a major city in Bayfield County, Wisconsin, United States. It’s a small town with a population of about 586 as of 2020.

Though lightly populated, Bayfield boasts beautiful maritime museums, fruit orchards, hotels, and restaurants.

There are quite a few fun places to visit at Bayfield. Some include Bayfield Maritime Museum, Mt Ashwabay Ski & Recreation Area, Halvor Reiten Park & Public Beach, and Apostle Highlands Golf Course. These are some of Bayfield’s parks and historical spots.

There are also wonderful hotels like Legendary Waters Resort & Casino, The Bayfield Inn, and more.

Are you planning a visit to Bayfield, WI? Below is a list of the best restaurants in Bayfield, WI.

Best Restaurants in Bayfield

1. The Copper Trout

The Copper Trout

The Copper Trout is one of the best restaurants in Bayfield, WI. It is a homey eatery featuring pizza, steak, seafood such as trout, and American entrees. The Copper Trout specializes in preparing tasty trout, either cooked, smoked, or grilled.

They also specialize in making whitefish dishes. You can’t be wrong going to The Copper Trout if you want to eat delicious trout and whitefish. The Copper Trout is a family-owned restaurant located in downtown Bayfield, WI, within walking distance of many other restaurants, shops, and boat tours.

As a lakeside restaurant, you can expect to be served only the freshest seafood any time you dine there. The Copper Trout serves surf & turf, wild mushroom pesto, wild mushroom bruschetta, calamari, Wisconsin cheese curds, and more.

The trout dishes they serve include smoked trout crostini and wild trout Madeline. The whitefish dishes they serve include superior whitefish chowder and blackened whitefish tostada. These seafood offerings are all delicious and have received a lot of praise online. The Copper Trout leads the way in food quality, affordable prices, and friendly customer service throughout Bayfield County.

Address: 250 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-5046. Phone: +1 715-779-0293

2. Manypenny Bistro

Manypenny Bistro

Manypenny Bistro is one of the top restaurants in Bayfield, WI. They serve classic American breakfast, dinner, and pub drinks. It is a great place to eat breakfast, lunch, and dinner in Bayfield, Wisconsin.

Some of the foods on the restaurant’s menu include fish tacos, fish sandwiches, sweet potato fries, crabby benny, falafel, hashbrown, and more. They serve cocktails like Bloody Marys and shakes like the hot chocolate milkshake. Manypenny serves whitefish taco, pepperoni pizza, blackened chicken, whitefish Reuben sandwich, and cheeseburger.

A good choice at this eatery is buffalo wings with a Mediterranean salad. Add that with one or two slices of pizza, and you’ll be filled. The burger section of the menu offers variety. Sandwiches, salads, and drinks are items Manypenny doesn’t lack at any point in time.

This restaurant is very receptive to groups and tourists. It is suitable for group dining as well as solo dining. Manypenny Bistro has outdoor seating, which allows you to soak in the lakeside views. They provide dine-in, takeaway, and delivery service options to all Bayfield and Bayfield County customers.

Address: 201 Manypenny Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-5028. Phone: +1 715-913-0303

3. Pier Plaza Restaurant & Pickled Herring Lounge

Pier Plaza Restaurant & Pickled Herring Lounge

This Bayfield eatery is a longtime, family-run joint at Bay Front Inn. They serve seafood dishes and regional beers in a casual setting and with a desirable outdoor deck. Pier Plaza Restaurant is one of the best restaurants in Bayfield, WI.

Pier Plaza Restaurant has a great beer variety to select from. They have a good number of cocktails, wines, and coffee types. Some of the food they serve include fish fries, fish & chips, fish sandwiches, steak sandwiches, fish tacos, and so on. PP also serves ahi tuna bowl, chicken wings, surf & turf, and more interesting food and drinks.

Some of the drinks PP offers include bloody Mary, mojito, Ukrainian iced coffee, and Italian red wine. We recommend the restaurant’s braised beef short rib. It is seriously delicious. The same can be said of their portabella mushroom Swiss cheeseburger. The restaurant opens daily at 11 am and closes by 8.30-9 pm.

Address: 1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-5018. Phone: +1 715-779-3330

4. The Bayfield Inn

The Bayfield Inn

The Bayfield Inn is one of the best hotels in Bayfield. Moreover, The Bayfield Inn restaurant inside this 3-star hotel stands out as one of the best restaurants in the area. They serve a variety of food goodies ranging from quick bites to comforting cuisine.

Some of the items you can expect to find on their menu include braised ribs, grilled whitefish, whitefish soup, beef sandwiches, surf & turf, bacon eggs, hamburgers, and more. The head chef, Chef Duey, is an eight-time consecutive winner of the Chequamegon Chefs Expedition. So you can expect nothing but fine dining experiences with Bayfield Inn.

Address: 20 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-5018. Phone: +1 715-779-3363

5. Landmark Restaurant at Old Rittenhouse Inn

Landmark Restaurant at Old Rittenhouse Inn

So you want a fine dining experience in Parsippany? You can experience it if you go to Landmark Restaurant at Old Rittenhouse Inn. Landmark Restaurant is a fine dining restaurant with upscale foods, including classic American fare. They serve high-quality food in a contemporary setting, making it an ideal place for fun nights if you live in Bayfield, WI.

Landmark Restaurant at Old Rittenhouse Inn provides a list of world-class wines and Michelin-star meals to all customers. You can be sure to enjoy Lobster Bisque and a generous pour of wine as you enjoy the well-lit, contemporary environment. They serve the likes of seared duck breast, champagne chicken, steak Bercy, veggie scramble, and bacon-wrapped chicken livers.

Landmark Restaurant is one of the top restaurants in Bayfield, WI. They open only on Fridays and Saturdays by 5 pm and close by 8.30-9 pm each day.

Address: 301 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-5016. Phone: +1 715-779-5111

6. Greunke’s First Street Inn & Dining

Greunke's First Street Inn & Dining

This restaurant is located inside Greunke’s First Street Inn. It is one of the best restaurants for Bayfield residents and tourists. They serve delicious breakfast and lunch specials here at Greuke’s First Street Inn & Dining.

Greuke’s restaurant is renowned for its delicious fish boils, pizza, and seafood dishes such as seared scallops and shrimp. They sell pizza at Sgt. Pepperoni’s which is next door to the restaurant. Greuke’s Inn Restaurant was founded in April 2005. It has been nominated as one of the ’10 favorite breakfast spots in Wisconsin.’

One of their best foods is their fresh Lake Superior Trout & Whitefish platter. It is offered in big portions; thus, it is suitable for group dining.

They serve pasta, steak, sandwiches, soups, and salads to everyone entering their door.

Address: 17 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-5018. Phone: +1 715-779-5480

7. Sargent pepperoni’s

Sargent pepperoni's

Sargent Pepperoni’s is an amazing pizza restaurant and one of the best places to eat in Bayfield, WI.

It is a pizzeria chain that has many branches nationwide serving high-quality pizza, calzones, and breakfast meals. It is partly integrated with Greuke’s Restaurant, as discussed earlier.

One customer favorite here is Sgt. Peppers work pizza. It is a mix of pepperoni, sausage, onion, and mushroom pizza flavors. It is seriously delicious and satisfying, even for a hungry bodybuilder. Sgt. Peppers work pizza comes in small, large, extra-large, and jumbo sizes like every pizza on the menu.

Suppose you want to be informed on the other pizza types sold at Sgt. Pepperoni’s pizzeria, visit Grueke’s Restaurant website.

Remember that you can order classic American breakfast foods at Sgt Pepperoni’s. This food establishment is open by 2 pm and closes by 9 pm daily.

Address: 21 N 1st Street, Bayfield, WI. Phone: +1 715-779-0153

8. Gourmet Garage

Gourmet Garage

Gourmet Garage is the best bakery in Bayfield, WI. Gourmet Garage makes brownies, donuts, cookies, bread, and cakes. It is undoubtedly the highest-rated bakery in Bayfield, Wisconsin.

This bakery is a traditional bakery that is situated perfectly in the heart of Bayfield. It makes pastries using old-time recipes with a little bit of modern touch. They serve apple fritters, cinnamon rolls, éclair with custard, chocolate chip muffins, hot cross buns, sugar cookies, bacon eggs, and more.

The menu highlights apple pie, apple cherry pie, blueberry & raspberry sandwich, caramel pecan roll, cake donuts, Cornish pastries, and more. One of the yummiest things to order from Gourmet Garage is their caramel pecan cheesecake. It is seriously delicious and is undoubtedly kids’ favorite.

Gourmet Garage is like a haven for anything that is baked because it produces a lot of pastries and confectioneries. They open by 8 am and close by 3 pm daily except Mon-Wed. They offer gluten-free food options, and all offerings are reasonably priced.

Address: 85130 State Highway 13, Bayfield, WI 54814-4540. Phone: +1 715-779-5365

Want more places to visit in Wisconsin? Here is a guide on restaurants in Plymouth, restaurants in Fort Atkinson, and restaurants in Burlington for an amazing meal time.

9. Wonderstate Coffee – Bayfield

Wonderstate Coffee – Bayfield

Wonderstate Coffee is the top coffee shop to be at in the morning. Wonderstate Coffee specializes in making coffee, tea, and food pairings. They roast organic coffee beans and make sweet-tasting coffee drinks for all customers. They claim on their website to be “the coziest cafe” in Bayfield, Wisconsin.

In reference to Wonderstate’s coffee, this is one word to describe them – superb. Their mocha latte is great, and the same can be said of their cortado, cappuccino, and cold brew coffee. Muffins and waffles are widely available for all to pair up with coffee.

The staff are usually professional, friendly and deliver fast service. So in all, you get great-tasting coffee at a great price, fast service, and yummy breakfast food items. What’s not to like about Wonderstate? There are non-dairy and gluten-free drink options for customers who are lactose-intolerant and allergic to gluten.

Some of the breakfast food they serve besides coffee are pretzels, hamburgers, cheeseburgers, and various types of sandwiches. You can order a cold frozen chai tea at noon and find it refreshing. Theirs is highly recommended on a sunny Bayfield afternoon while at the beachside. Wonderstate opens by 7 am and closes by 2 pm daily.

Address: 117 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814-4968. Phone: +1 715-913-0330

10. Morty’s Pub

Morty’s Pub

Just a block away from Lake Superior, you will find Morty’s Pub on Rittenhouse Avenue, Bayfield. Morty’s Pub is the best place to drink while chatting with family, friends, or fellow tourists. Morty’s Pub is a good spot for that.

It is the highest-rated pub in Bayfield, WI. It serves craft beers, name-brand beers, and international drinks and cocktails. They offer dine-in and takeaway options for all customers. Aside from alcoholic drinks, Morty’s Pub also serves whitefish tacos, pretzel bites, fish & chips, fried bologna sandwiches, Wisconsin cheese curds, huevos rancheros, and hamburgers.

We’d say keep it simple at Morty’s Pub; just go for a chicken sandwich eaten along with bloody Mary. It is a tasty and satisfying drink-food combination. Chicken wings or grilled chicken can be another great choice. Eating classic pub foods while having your beer is the ideal theme Morty’s Pub promotes.

Address: 108 Rittenhouse Avenue, Bayfield, WI 54814+1 715-779-3996

11. Portside Bar and Restaurant

Portside Bar and Restaurant

Portside Bar & Restaurant is one of the best restaurants in Bayfield, WI. They prepare and serve fresh Lake Superior trout and whitefish, among other seafood choices. They also prepare and serve homemade soups, locally made gourmet desserts, and cocktails.

You can enjoy your steaks, seafood, salads, and sandwiches inside the dining room or outdoors. Portside menu highlights deep-fried fresh Lake Superior trout, chicken piccata, medium rare prime rib, fettuccine alfredo, and more.

Their deep-fried fresh Lake Superior whitefish, trout, and Canadian walleye are one of the restaurant’s favorites. Char-grilled shrimp with rice pilaf is another delicious food served at Portside Bar & Restaurant. You can enjoy yourself with either of the above and drink cold drinks as you eat.

The restaurant’s most notorious drink is Stella Artois, a local beer brand. It is suitable to order it as a food pair. That way, you save a small amount, and you double your enjoyment of the food and drink at hand. Portside operates only on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays. On those days, they open only in the evening time from 4 pm to 9 pm.

Address: 34475 Port Superior Rd, Bayfield, WI 54814-4937+1 715-779-5380

12. Beach Club

Beach Club

Beach Club on Madeline Island is the best bar and grill spot in La Pointe, just about 2.7 miles away from Bayfield. The Beach Club has been proudly serving grilled and pub fare to Madeline Island since 1936.

At its founding, Lee Russel wanted The Beach Club on Madeline Island to be where tourists, year-rounders, and the island’s summer residents would come. Beach Club is now run by the Wiltz Family, who purchased it in 2004.

It is one of the best places to eat in Bayfield, WI. You can have a barbecue, seafood, and beers while having lively conservations with friends & family around you. It serves delicious fish sandwiches, chicken strips, whitefish chowder, and whitefish tacos to island dwellers and visitors alike.

Address: 817 Fort Road, La Pointe, WI. Phone: +1 715-747-3955

13. Tom’s Burned Down Café

Tom’s Burned Down Café

Tom’s Burned Down Café is one of the best restaurants in the lakeshore area of Wisconsin. The name and the physical surrounding suggest it is a renovated bar. They mainly sell cocktail drinks and beer, but some pub fares are available.

Tom’s Burned Down Café makes Bloody Mary, margarita, mojito, and other cocktails. They also have beers available, ranging from Duluth Cider to Island Hopper beer cans.

The bar has outdoor seating. Some of the drinks are brand names, while an expert bartender locally makes some. They open around noon and close by 7-8 pm daily.

Address: 234 Middle Rd, La Pointe, WI 54850-0222. Phone: +1 717-747-6100

14. Grampa Tony’s

Grampa Tony’s

This is one of the best restaurants around the Apostle Islands in Lake Superior. It is located on Main Street, La Pointe, WI. Their website claims their restaurant is approximately a 20mins ferry ride from Bayfield, WI.

Grampa Tony’s serves pizza, wraps, sandwiches, salads, ice cream, and breakfast classics. They offer garlic burgers, chicken Caesar wraps, Benedict Omelettes, smoothies, pancakes, pepperoni pizza, and more.

You would likely enjoy Grampa Tony’s chef salad. It is well-prepared and sumptuous. The restaurant offers nice fish sandwiches for breakfast or brunch while you’re exploring Madeline Island. The restaurant opens by 11 am and closes by 8 pm from Mon-Thurs.

Address: 814 Main St, La Pointe, WI 54850-2400. Phone: +1 715-747-3911

15. Farmhouse Madeline Island

Farmhouse Madeline Island

The farmhouse restaurant on Madeline Island is called Farmhouse Kitchen and Inn. The restaurant is managed by Gilpin Matthews and Lauren Schuppe, who has endeavored to keep the food quality high. They operate the restaurant so successively by getting ingredients from as near as possible.

This eatery serves hash browns, pesto eggs, deviled eggs, waffles, smoked yolk & Caesar salad, meatloaf burgers, Friday fish fry, and more. The farmhouse is more of a breakfast café than a diner restaurant. So they are not open throughout the day. For now, Farmhouse on Madeline Island opens shop only on Sundays from 9 am to 2 pm.

The farmhouse restaurant concludes our list of the top Bayfield restaurants.

Address: 858 Main St, Fort Road, La Pointe, WI 54850-2400+1 715-747-3276

Check out our list of the best restaurants in Beloit and restaurants in Stevens Point for an amazing meal time in Wisconsin.

Plan a Trip to Bayfield

Being that Bayfield is a sparely populated lakeside town, it is expected that the community is socially intact. Most residents know each other because they work and school in similar locations.

Bayfield restaurants mostly cater to the needs of the thousands of visitors who come to Bayfield for summer music festivals, beach parties, museum tours, and kayaking.

The restaurants in Bayfield are decent enough, and their food quality is high, even for food critics. Eating at one of the top Bayfield restaurants offers you views of Apostle Islands National Lakeshore and others.

Plan a trip to Bayfield today!