15 Best Restaurants in Algoma (WI)

If you are searching for the best restaurants in Algoma, WI, then you are in the right place.

Door County is an intriguing destination with many charming seaside communities that integrate seamlessly into each other as you traverse the unspoiled coasts.

Each town has distinct characteristics that set them apart, and Algoma is no exception.

With a population of about 3219 people, the locality has some activities facilitated by recreational zones and community parks.

For numerous years, many travelers have been frequenting this serene expanse of coastline to bask in its tranquil ambiance, secluded setting that enhances an enjoyable Door County getaway, and beautiful cuisines.

Are you planning a visit to Algoma, WI? Here are the top restaurants in Algoma, WI.

Best Restaurants in Algoma, Wisconsin:

1. Son of Skaliwags

Son of Skaliwags

With fond memories of the meals from the south coast from his upbringing and shaping his skills under the blistering grill and the tutelage of his father, Chef Marshall infuses his personal touch into the celebrated Skaliwags tradition.

In 2011, Son of Skaliwags was inaugurated, and this top Algoma restaurant not only offers the beloved Skaliwags’ classics but also presents innovative and distinctive culinary creations.

Their increasing connection to the Algoma community helps them utilize locally sourced ingredients whenever feasible, complementing the meals they serve.

Their popular dishes include crispy shrimp, blackened grouper, beef, fried lobster appetizer, filet mignon, shrimp and grits, ribeye steak, and crab cakes.

They operate Sundays, Mondays, and Thursdays from 4:30 pm to 8:00 pm, Tuesdays from 4:00 pm to 8:00 pm, and weekends from 4:30 am to 9:00 pm.

Address: 312 Clark St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-536-1539.

2. Algoma Pizza Bowl

Algoma Pizza Bowl

If you are craving yummy, tasty food, Algoma Pizza Bowl caters to the entire family and serves as one of the best restaurants in Algoma, WI.

Algoma Pizza Bowl presents an excellent place for family reunions and children’s birthday celebrations. Moreover, the restaurant features a bowling alley that operates during regular business hours, adding to its appeal.

You can have fried cheese, hand-battered onion rings, wings, gourmet burgers, and specialty pizzas like barbeque chicken and BLT pizza.

Opening hours are Wednesdays and Thursdays from 4:00 pm to 9:00 pm on Wednesdays and Thursdays, Fridays from 4:00 pm to 11:00 pm, Saturdays from 2:00 pm to 11:00 pm, and Sundays from 4:00 pm to 10:00 pm.

Address: 401 2nd St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-2721.

3. Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub

Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub

With its bustling atmosphere, Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub stands out as one of the most vibrant establishments on the West end of Sturgeon Bay.

Kitty O’Reillys, situated within strolling distance of a few shops and the marina, beautifully captures the essence of traditional Ireland through its meals.

This restaurant features a thrilling escapade with beautiful al fresco seating, a wonderful, intimate dining area, and an exciting tavern.

The menu contains some of the dearest flavors of the Emerald Isle, such as shrimp tacos, lobster rolls, calamari, pulled pork sandwiches, Irish stew, lobster roll appetizer, and Guinness BBQ ribs.

Opening hours are Mondays through Thursdays from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm, Fridays from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm, and Saturdays to Sundays from 8:00 am to 10:00 pm.

Address: 59 E Oak St, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States. Phone: +1 920-743-7441.

4. North Water Bakery & the Captain’s Gallery Room

North Water Bakery & the Captain’s Gallery Room

What’s a vacation without indulging in delectable treats and yummy desserts for those with a knack for sweet things?

The North Water Bakery & Deli, renowned for the artistic creations of JoAnn’s cake designs, has broadened its horizons by transforming into a comprehensive bakery and deli.

This exclusive establishment is authorized to operate and specializes in numerous confectionaries.

At North Water, you also have the freedom to exercise your creativity by designing your culinary masterpiece from their range of cakes, ice cream pies, and sandwiches.

What makes them even more convenient is that they can create a bespoke wedding cake for your special day to mark that traditional centerpiece and sentimental value as a cherished memory of your occasion.

The North Water menu features chili, a Western omelet platter, corn beef hash, breakfast burritos, pork chop breakfast, hot ham and cheese, and grilled chicken.

The Bakery Hours are Mondays through Fridays from 5:00 am to 5:00 pm and Saturdays from 5:00 am to 1:00 pm.

The Captain’s Gallery Rooms is open Mondays through Fridays from 7:00 am to 1:00 pm and Saturdays to Sundays from 7:00 am to 12:00 pm.

Address: 133 North Water Street, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-5306.

5. Off The Hook Bar-n-Grill

For those looking for a beautiful, fantastic time, Off The Hook is the ultimate destination, serving up superb options like grilled steak tips and fresh seafood, along with a lively ambiance.

With a deep appreciation of sourcing locally, the restaurant makes a point to visit nearby fish markets, converse and engage with commercial fishers, and keep abreast of seasonal trends to offer the absolute best to customers.

Adding to the lively atmosphere, Off The Hook features bar games, while their staff ensures that customers always have a fantastic time.

Featuring great sandwiches and wraps like chicken Philly cheese sandwiches, veggie wrap, BLT, and grilled chicken melt. You can also get burgers, fish fries, and beverages.

Opening hours are 11:00 am to 2:00 am daily. Feel free to add this restaurant to your list of best restaurants in Algoma, WI, to visit.

Address: 205 Navarino St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-8075.

6. Trattoria Dal Santo

Trattoria Dal Santo

Trattoria Del Santo presents a distinct encounter with Northern Italian cuisine complemented by a selection of beer and wines.

This restaurant boasts a storefront venue with an upscale ambiance, an in-house bar, and chic seating options.

They are committed to high-quality meals and products, featuring fritto di calamari, pesto torta, beer cheese soup, stuffed grilled pork chop, and Italian favorites like fettuccine Alfredo, lasagna al forno, and mostaccioli rapido.

Indulge in a romantic Italian dining experience in Sturgeon Bay that won’t break the bank. Here you can enjoy the meals, appreciate the wine, and surround yourself with Italy’s beautiful charm when you visit Trattoria Dal Santo.

Visit Trattoria Dal Santo Tuesdays through Saturdays from 5:00 pm to 9:00 pm. It is also among the best Algoma restaurants.

Address: Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States. Phone: +1 920-743-6100.

7. Caffe Tlazo

Caffe Tlazo

Caffe Tlazo is one of the best breakfast and brunch establishments in Algoma, Wisconsin, featuring top-notch meals and beverages.

This popular restaurant has many visitors who make it a regular pit stop en route to Door County and from it.

Housed in an aesthetically refurbished 1891 Italianate mansion, it exudes elegance and sophistication.

Caffe Tlazo, conveniently located with easily accessible parking, offers vegan and vegetarian meals, organic food, gluten-free alternatives, and beverage options.

The aim here is to provide great merchandise and comprehensive knowledge thereof, accompanied by sublime customer service, a serene ambiance, and a pledge to offer nutritious, innovative options.

The menu features lattes, sandwiches, oatmeal, crepes, eggwich – prosciutto ham, paninis, and breakfast burritos.

Visit Caffe Tlazo Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays from 6:30 am to 2:00 pm and Saturdays to Sundays from 7:00 am to 2:00 pm.

Address: 607 4th St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-7240.

8. Sonny’s Italian Kitchen and Pizzeria

Sonny’s Italian Kitchen and Pizzeria

Next on this list of top restaurants in Algoma, WI, is Sonny’s Italian Pizzeria.

For over two decades now, Sonny’s Italian Pizzeria has been a prominent player in the culinary scene of Door County, tirelessly striving to be a leading provider of incredible Chicago-style pizza.

Sonny’s Italian Kitchen offers a gastronomic experience with serene waterfront vistas. Their online ordering is practical and accessible, and their services are apt and convenient.

With a menu full of garlic bread, cheese curds, chicken parmesan, Nashville hot chicken, rigatoni boscaiola, and fine wines like Cavit Pinot Grigio, and Sea Sun Pinot Noir, this is one of the top-ranking dining establishments in the city.

They operate weekdays from 11:00 am to 8:30 pm and weekends from 11:00 am to 9:30 pm.

Address: 129 N Madison Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States. Phone: +1 920-743-2300.

Are you planning a food tour in Wisconsin? Here is a guide on restaurants in Veronarestaurants in Delavan, and restaurants in Bayfield for a fun meal time.

9. Dairy Dean’s Family Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlor

Dairy Dean’s Family Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlor

The fantastic Dairy Dean’s Family Restaurant restores the joy of meals and frozen treats throughout the year, thanks to a team of devoted staff committed to ensuring guests have a beautiful breakfast/brunch experience.

This is one of the best Algoma restaurants that uphold high standards of excellence by obtaining the best products from nearby farmers’ markets without any concessions.

Indulge in the savory goodness of Dairy Dean’s Family Restaurant through takeout, dine-in, or delivery, and satisfy your cravings by placing an order today.

Almost every type of food you can imagine is included in their menu. You can get meat lovers skillet, Alaskan waffles, French toast, grits, Dean’s omelet, BLT, hamburger and fries, and breakfast burrito.

They operate daily from 7:00 am to 2:00 pm.

Address: 824 4th St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-5668.

10. China Moon

China Moon integrates their love for producing great food with a wealth of knowledge in the beautiful art. This, in turn, results in the creation of fabulous dishes for your indulgence.

This is one of the best places to eat in Algoma, WI, committed to getting locally procured ingredients that make for a thrilling experience.

By placing your order through their website, you contribute to their ability to offer exceptional service and premium-grade ingredients, to yield a satisfactory takeout experience.

China Moon delights guests with meals like pupu platter, cashew chicken, shrimp with snow peas and white rice, egg or vegetable fried rice, roast pork or chicken lo mein, and shrimp with lobster sauce

Operating hours are Tuesdays through Sundays from 10:00 am to 9:00 pm.

Address: 709 N Water St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-9881

11. Old Mexico Cantina & Grill

At Old Mexico Cantina & Grill, a deep love for Mexican cuisine permeates the atmosphere.

The restaurant proudly embodies the authenticity of Mexican food, originating from Mexico and enriched with innovative concepts derived from Minnesota and South Carolina.

Employing only the most exquisite and recently harvested components, they aim to offer a sensation and flavor of old Mexican cuisine.

Old Mexico Cantina features an extensive menu of well-known Mexican and Tex-Mex dishes, such as enchiladas del mar, beef quesadillas, steak tacos, chicken fajitas, burrito de carnitas, and camarones rancheros.

Visit Old Mexican Cantina from 11:00 am to 9:00 pm on weekdays and weekends from 11:00 am to 10:00 pm. It is also worth adding to your list of top Algoma  restaurants.

Address: 901 Egg Harbor Road, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States. Phone: +1 920-818-1500.

12. Greystone Castle

Greystone Castle

The Greystone Castle, situated at the convergence of the two bridges on the western end of Door County, has been under the proprietorship of the Ebel family for more than 35 years.

This locally run restaurant is deeply embedded in the fabric of the community.

For a long time, Greystone has remained the top pick for residents and visitors drawn to its longstanding reputation for beautiful food and great drinks.

Adorned on the walls of the eatery are taxidermy showcases of majestic wild creatures and marine life. The exclusive mounted Sturgeon on display is a unique gem in Sturgeon Bay and Door County.

This hunting and fishing-themed restaurant offer delectable meals like stuffed shrimp, brake brush flappers, cucumber salad, creamy prime rib delight, and steak sandwiches.

They are open every day from 9:00 am to 2:00 am on weekdays and 9:00 am to 2:30 am on weekends.

Address: 8 N Madison Ave, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States. Phone: +1 920-743-9923.

13. A&W Restaurant

When it comes to burgers and root beer floats, A&W reigns supreme. The restaurant commenced in 1919, serving its signature cold and frothy root beer to parched customers on scorching afternoons.

A&W has numerous outlets in different parts of the nation. The company has maintained a solid connection to the tight-knit communities that have long been its support pillars.

Drive-through, dine-in, and takeout are popular service options in A&W Restaurant.

This fast food outlet features hot dogs,, chicken tender sandwiches, cod sandwiches, chili cheese fries, and onion rings. It is undoubtedly one of the top Algoma restaurants.

Opening hours are 10:00 am to 8:00 pm on weekdays and 10:00 am to 9:00 pm on weekdays.

Address: 1025 Lake St, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-8236.

14. Red’s Pub & Grill

Red’s Pub & Grill, one of the top restaurants in Algoma, WI, is a remarkable destination for indulging in delicious food and refreshing drinks while basking in the serene nearby lake setting.

The dining establishment’s casual adornment creates a comfortable atmosphere for a relaxed dining experience.

What amplifies the enjoyment of the experience here at Red’s Pub & Grill is the specials like Prime Rib Saturdays and happy hour. They also feature pinball machines and various board games suitable for those not inclined towards pinball.

The menu highlights Wisconsin classics like chicken quesadillas, grilled chicken salads, bourbon steak, grilled yellowfin tuna, chicken tenders, certified Angus beef steaks, and jalapeno poppers for your enjoyment.

Drop by Red’s Pub for the time of your life on Tuesdays to Fridays from 4:00 pm to 9:00 pm and Saturdays from 3:00 pm to 9:00 pm.

Address: N6318 WI-42, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-677-8499.

15. Homestead Kitchen and Tap

Homestead Kitchen and Tap

The Ebert Enterprises clan proudly owns Homestead Kitchen and Tap, a restaurant that adheres to the farm-to-fork ethos.

Similar to the revolving blades of a windmill, this is one of the best places to eat in Algoma, WI, that maintains its practice of ensuring guests are treated to healthy, quality meals.

For years, the family has been diligently laboring to complete their farm to establish a self-contained system, known as a “loop,” that prioritizes ethical practices throughout every stage of food production.

Enjoy pretzels, Homestead burgers, walleye plates, fried ravioli, tender mercies, taco salads, haystack onion rings, nachos platter, and cheeseburgers.

Homestead is open Thursdays through Saturdays from 3:30 pm to 9:00 pm and Sundays from 9:30 am to 1:30 pm.

Address: N7551 Co Rd D, Algoma, WI 54201, United States. Phone: +1 920-487-0105.

Also, check out our guide on restaurants in Spring Green, restaurants in Portage , and restaurants in Stevens Point for a memorable meal time in Wisconsin.

Plan a Trip to Algoma, Wisconsin

Algoma guarantees a splendid time, whether your plans involve catching a prized fish in Lake Michigan or sinking your toes in the beautiful sandy beach and boardwalk.

Your vacation can also entail treating yourself to wine from esteemed wineries following a day of exploring and retail therapy. Whatever you choose to do, Algoma is ready to have your needs taken care of.